Showing posts with label Strike. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Strike. Show all posts

Friday, February 15, 2008

WGA Strike: Back to Work


From 236.com. Click for LARGE.

Strike Over. Contract Vote in Progress.

Writers went back to work Wednesday.

Contract vote is next week. It will be approved.

United Hollywood

This was sent [Tuesday] to WGA members from Presidents Verrone and Winship:

To Our Fellow Members:

On Tuesday, members of the Writers Guilds East and West voted by a 92.5% margin to lift the restraining order that was invoked on November 5th. The strike is over.

Writing can resume immediately. If you were employed when the strike began, you should plan to report to work on Wednesday. If you're not employed at an office or other work site, call or e-mail your employer that you are resuming work. If you have been told not to report to work or resume your services, we recommend that you still notify your employer in writing of your availability to do so. Questions concerning return-to-work issues should be directed to the WGAW legal department at 323.782.4521 or the WGAE’s assistant executive director Ann Toback at 212-767-7823.

The decision to begin this strike was not taken lightly and was only made after no other reasonable alternative was possible. We are profoundly aware of the economic loss these fourteen weeks have created not only for our members but so many other colleagues who work in the television and motion picture industries. Nonetheless, with the establishment of the WGA jurisdiction over new media and residual formulas based on distributor’s gross revenue (among other gains) we are confident that the results are a significant achievement not only for ourselves but the entire creative community, now and in the future.

We hope to build upon the extraordinary energy, ingenuity, and solidarity that were generated by your hard work during the strike.

Over the next weeks and months, we will be in touch with you to discuss and develop ways we can use our unprecedented unity to make our two guilds stronger and more effective than ever.

Now that the strike has ended, there remains the vote to ratify the new contract. Ballots and information on the new deal, both pro and con, will be mailed to you shortly. You will be able to return those ballots via mail or at a membership meeting to be held Monday, February 25th, 2008, at times and locations to be determined.

Thank you for making it possible. As ever, we are all in this together.

Best,

Patric M. Verrone
President, WGAW

Michael Winship
President, WGAE
The writers lost the 1988 strike. Badly.

The strike lasted five months.

Eventually with the union splintering, writers going financial core, everyone turning on each other and the studios laughing, the writers gave up. After having shut down production for five full months, the WGA took the same deal offered at month three. With a smidge of change for saving face and not much of a smidge.

That was twenty years ago.

Joan Didion wrote an essay about the 1988 strike for The New Yorker. Explains Los Angeles, the politics, and writers staying out that extra hopeless two months.

'Cause even though this time was about new media -- and it was -- the failure of 1988 was never far from anyone's mind.

Meet the old boss, same as the new boss... Los Angeles Days.
There's more...

Sunday, February 10, 2008

WGA Strike: A Tentative Deal



Almost Over.

The graph from last January of falling studio stock prices, shows why.

Writers met Saturday in New York City and Los Angeles to hear the proposal. The New York City membership (WGAE) generally was for lifting the strike. I don't have word yet on Los Angeles (WGAw.)

The Board can a) lift the strike on its own, b) schedule a 48 hour vote, or c) schedule a 10 day vote. I think option b, a 48 hour vote is most politically likely. That puts everyone back to work Wednesday, yet lets everyone be clear it is their choice to take this contract. Which in my view is as it should be, after this much sacrifice and work.

If the writers don't take the deal, most of it will be withdrawn. They will lose all their leverage -- the Academy Awards, Upfronts (selling the fall season), pilot season, hiring for the fall shows -- till June when SAG joins them on the picket lines. That's three more months of walking in circles for nothing, as there is no guarantee they'll get any better deal then.

The writers will take the deal (I say confidently.) Not perfect, but no negotiation is.

United Hollywood

Letter From The Presidents With Deal Summary

This was sent early this morning to membership. The delay in publishing the deal points, we've learned, was because the companies dragged their feet enshrining some of the final details in an attempt to renege on some of what they had promised. The last-minute fight to keep that from happening took until late last night.

To Our Fellow Members,

We have a tentative deal.

It is an agreement that protects a future in which the Internet becomes the primary means of both content creation and delivery. It creates formulas for revenue-based residuals in new media, provides access to deals and financial data to help us evaluate and enforce those formulas, and establishes the principle that, "When they get paid, we get paid."

Specific terms of the agreement are described in the summary at the following link - http://www.wga.org/contract_07/wga_tent_summary.pdf - and will be further discussed at our Saturday membership meetings on both coasts. At those meetings we will also discuss how we will proceed regarding ratification of this agreement and lifting the restraining order that ends the strike. Details of the Los Angeles meeting can be found at http://www.wga.org/subpage_member.aspx?id=2763.

Less than six months ago, the AMPTP wanted to enact profit-based residuals, defer all Internet compensation in favor of a study, forever eliminate "distributor's gross" valuations, and enforce 39 pages of rollbacks to compensation, pension and health benefits, reacquisition, and separated rights. Today, thanks to three months of physical resolve, determination, and perseverance, we have a contract that includes WGA jurisdiction and separated rights in new media, residuals for Internet reuse, enforcement and auditing tools, expansion of fair market value and distributor's gross language, improvements to other traditional elements of the MBA, and no rollbacks.

Over these three difficult months, we shut down production of nearly all scripted content in TV and film and had a serious impact on the business of our employers in ways they did not expect and were hard pressed to deflect. Nevertheless, an ongoing struggle against seven, multinational media conglomerates, no matter how successful, is exhausting, taking an enormous personal toll on our members and countless others. As such, we believe that continuing to strike now will not bring sufficient gains to outweigh the potential risks and that the time has come to accept this contract and settle the strike.

Much has been achieved, and while this agreement is neither perfect nor perhaps all that we deserve for the countless hours of hard work and sacrifice, our strike has been a success. We activated, engaged, and involved the membership of our Guilds with a solidarity that has never before occurred. We developed a captains system and a communications structure that used the Internet to build bonds within our membership and beyond. We earned the backing of other unions and their members worldwide, the respect of elected leaders and politicians throughout the nation, and the overwhelming support of fans and the general public. Our thanks to all of them, and to the staffs at both Guilds who have worked so long and patiently to help us all.

There is much yet to be done and we intend to use all the techniques and relationships we've developed in this strike to make it happen. We must support our brothers and sisters in SAG who, as their contract expires in less than five months, will be facing many of the same challenges we have just endured. We must further pursue new relationships we have established in Washington and in state and local governments so that we can maintain leverage against the consolidated multinational conglomerates with whom we bargain. We must be vigilant in monitoring the deals that are made in new media so that in the years ahead we can enforce and expand our contract. We must fight to get decent working conditions and benefits for writers of reality TV, animation, and any other genre in which writers do not have a WGA contract.

Most important, however, is to continue to use the new collective power we have generated for our collective benefit. More than ever, now and beyond, we are all in this together.

Best,

Patric M. Verrone
President, WGAW

Michael Winship
President, WGAE
Has the strike been worth it?

Bet your ass.

The studios tried to steal the internet. Failed.

You did that.

Without massive support from everyone, from readers of blogs, to the ordinary television viewer, to the people at my breakfast diner, from actors and the writers walking around in circles, this could not and would not have happened.

We're all in this together. Good work and congratulations.
There's more...

Saturday, February 9, 2008

WGA Strike: LA & NYC Meetings


See all speechless films in High Quality.

Not Over. Don't Believe Rumors. Or Articles.

Here's what you can believe.

There is an proposal.

It is currently being reduced from what was negotiated in the room between the principles -- our three negotiators, and two studio chairman -- to a long-form deal contract, by lawyers.

Their lawyers.

One step, one deal point, one sentence at a time.

As I write this, it should be finishing up. If it isn't... that would be bad.

I'll kick you to an article which says why.

The thing is, there is a negotiated deal. But it doesn't mean anything till it's reduced to a long-form deal in writing, because it's the final form which controls. And the lawyers try and shave off little bits here and there to please their studio bosses.

Which is why the pickets have been SO STRONG all week. To make it clear to the studio bosses whenever the lawyers have gone back to them and said, "The negotiators for the WGA have said, 'this isn't what the deal was' and they won't budge. What should we do?" The studio heads just look outside their window and see 150-200 picketers walking around in circles. Doesn't matter which window, which studio. There are the writers, on fucking strike.

And the order filters back down... "Yeah, that isn't what we negotiated. Quit fucking around and get the damn thing closed."

Today. Saturday. Two big meetings. One in New York City at the Crowne Plaza Hotel at Times Square, 2 PM ET for WGAE. One in Los Angeles at the Shrine Auditorium, 7 PM PT for WGAw. Maps at the links. These are union meetings. Current active members only, photo ID required.

Here is what is going on:

United Hollywood

The Strike Captains met at the WGA Theater today and we were allowed to look at the NOT FINISHED Terms Of Agreement. The reason that the Guild has not published them to everyone in the membership is because they ARE NOT FINISHED. In fact, still today the negotiating team has to fight the AMPTP lawyers on drafting legal language that the lawyers keep backsliding on – which sounds like, “Nope, my boss never agreed to that.” Then our leadership shows them their notes from the meeting. They say, “Well, here are our notes,” which contradict – so the leadership has to call up Chernin and Iger – who then have to call their lawyers and tell them to back-off. Then, the music stops and they scramble for chairs.

If the AMPTP lawyers don’t hammer out the legal language tonight in a fair way that was agreed upon by all parties, and get it signed by their CEO bosses by midnight tonight (the agreed upon deadline) then it only hurts the AMPTP and the entire town, because there is no way the leadership will show it to us until it’s finalized. They know too well how slippery these folks are – once you tell your membership this is what it will be – well then the lawyers have no incentive to improve on the legal language.

So, that is why you haven’t seen the terms and deal points yet. However, as soon as the ink is dry – they will be emailed to you both in summary and in longform immediately by your guild (East and West). Hopefully, that will be tonight, or early tomorrow morning. This way they can be studied and discussed before the general assemblies (East and West) tomorrow.

Generally, how is the deal?

Patric Verrone, Michael Winship, David Young, and John Bowman are all recommending the deal. They think it’s a good one – not perfect – but a good solid deal that we would never have gotten if we hadn’t have gone out on strike. They believe we got every last penny on the table. Like in any negotiation, neither side is 100% satisfied. But, on our side there are good gains, and notable gains in the area of New Media.

Okay, so what's going to happen at the Saturday meeting?

Well, if the document is signed and delivered – as it should be – the Negotiating Team will go over the document point by point. They will then outline what the steps moving forward might be:

1. If a majority of the assembly seems happy with the Terms of Agreement, and will likely ratify it – the greater board will take this into consideration when they meet on Sunday. Then, on Sunday they will vote on whether or not to lift the strike, and send everyone back to work on Monday. They will only vote to lift it if they feel that the majority of membership likes the deal and will ratify it. If that's the case – we go back to work on Monday. Meanwhile the traditional 10 day ratification process takes place: everyone receives ballots, sends in their vote, their vote is counted...

2. If at the assembly the feedback from the membership is that they are not happy with the deal and will likely not ratify it, then the board takes that into consideration when they vote on Sunday. If they vote not to lift the strike, we then stay out 10 more days as we ratify the vote. Keep in mind staying out 10 more days would hurt the rest of TV season, the Oscars, next year's pilot season, and the 2009 feature slate. This not only hurts the companies, it also hurts us, and the whole town.

3. If the board does not lift the strike, and we vote the deal down after the 10 day ratification process. Then, the Negotiating Team goes back to the drawing table, and begins negotiating again. This time around though, we’re likely to be out until SAG negotiates in June. An old timer mentioned that that’s the course the membership took in ’88, and they were out for 3 more months and got no notable gains. Our leverage right now is the rest of TV season, the Oscars, pilot season, and the 2009 feature slate - once we pass the point of no return on those we've lost leverage for a good while.

4. The 48 hour ratification process. If on Sunday the board votes not to lift the strike, then they could enact this process. However, this means robocalling, emailing, phoning, and getting in instant contact with every member to let them know that there will be a vote in the next 48 hours. This is called the notification period – not impossible… but not the best option because many numbers and email addresses for members are outdated – and the guild would want an accurate vote of all membership – not just the ones who update their contact information. The 10 day period gives more time for mailed ballots to find their owners. However, if the board decides to go with the 48 hour ratification process, and the majority of membership vote to ratify the terms, then we would likely be back at work on Wednesday.

I hope I’ve answered more questions than I’ve raised. I would suggest coming to the meeting tomorrow with an open mind. I would also highly suggest coming to the meeting tomorrow. It will not only ensure that you have all the information, and that your voice will be heard when the board measures their decision on Sunday, it will also ensure that the board gets a representative idea of where we stand as a membership.
And then there's this, by the Dude:
Joss Whedon

Do Not Adjust Your Mindset

This was submitted by WGA and DGA member Joss Whedon.

Dear Writers,

I have good news. I have lots of good news. In fact, I have way too much good news.

The strike is almost over. A resolution is days away. Weeks. Friday. Valentine's day. Two weeks exactly from whenever my manager/agent/lawyer told me. Yes, after talking to writers and actors all over town, I'm happy to report that the strike is going to end every single day until March. Huzzah! All of this entirely reliable information means that at last the dream of the writing community has been realized: the Oscars will be saved.

Let's step back.

The Oscars seem to be the point of focus for a lot of this speculation. That either they must be preserved, or that the studios feel they must be preserved, and therefore this terrible struggle will end. There is an argument to be made for wanting the show to go on: it showcases the artists with whom we are bonded (there's no award for Best Hiding of Net Profits), and it provides employment and revenue for thousands in the community that has been hit so hard by this action. Having said that, it's a f%$#ing awards show. It's a vanity fair. It's a blip. We're fighting (fighting, remember?) for the future of our union, our profession, our art. If that fight carries us through the Holy Night when Oscar was born, that's just too bad.

And the studios? Well, the Oscars provide advertising revenue and a boost for the films that win. But the studios have shown impressive resolve in ignoring short-term losses in order to destroy us. I don't hear any knees knocking in the Ivory Towers over that night of programming. Hey, I wish I did. I wish, like a lot of people, I could hear anything from in there besides that weird clicking sound Predator makes.

I ask you all to remember: the studios caused an industry-wide shutdown. They made a childishly amateurish show of pretending to negotiate, then retreated into their lairs (yes, they have lairs) to starve us out. They emerged just before Christmas to raise our hopes, then left in a premeditated huff. They Force Majoured with gay abandon, cutting deals and 'trimming the fat' (I've met a couple of 'the fat' on the picket lines. Nice guys.) and made every selfish, counter-intuitively destructive move in the Bully's Bible. They met with the DGA and resolved quickly, as expected.

We have been advised to tone down the anti-studio rhetoric now that a deal might be progressing. Our negotiators have the specific task of forgetting the past and dealing only with the numbers before them. Their ability to do that impresses me greatly, but I maintain that it's their job to treat the studios like business partners and it's our job to remember who they really are. The studios are inefficient, power-hungry, thieving corporate giants who have made the life of the working writer harder from decade to decade. They are run by men so out of touch with basic humanity that they would see Rome burn before they would think about the concept of fair compensation. I maintain that they have never revealed their true agenda in the causing and handling of this strike, and to expect them to now is cock-eyed optimism of the most dangerous kind.

I have heard people both in and out of the industry say, "But that's enough now, right?" I have seen the thing I fear most: that whatever their agenda, they are beating us down. With hope. With rumors. With Time. The mindset seems to be shifting to one of relief and even unspoken gratitude for their return, instead of flaming indignation that they ever (illegally, do you recall?) left the table in the first place. It's the mindset of the victim. The lethargy of limb that strikes the fighter as he unconsciously lets himself lose. The studio strategists have worked this scenario as carefully as they have everything else. It is so crucial that we outside of the talks remember that, and let them know we do.

This is not over. Nor is it close. Until the moment it is over, it can never be close. Because if we see the finish line we will flag and they are absolutely counting on us to do that. In the room, reason. On the streets, on the net, I say reason is for the 'moderates'. Remember what they've done. Remember what they're trying to take from us. FIGHT. FIGHT. FIGHT.

I have been mugged an embarrassing number of times, even for a New Yorker. I've been yelled at and chased, beaten down and kicked, threatened with a gun and the only mugger who still hurts my gut is the one who made me shake his hand. Until there is a deal – the right deal, not the DGA deal – held out, let's keep our hands in our pockets or on our signs. Let's not be victims. Let's never.

In solidarity,
Joss Whedon
Read more?

www.unitedhollywood.com
Deadline Hollywood
John August

Prediction: 70:30 it's over if the studios stop screwing the language.

No contract language, 20:80 no deal. Hell, 5:95. No one signs off without an actual something on which to sign. Neg Com wouldn't recommend. Board wouldn't approve. And Membership wouldn't vote it in.

Studios are playing a risky game by carving words under a ticking clock.

Baby go BOOM.

If you want to deeply understand the bullshit of the studios:

The Strike Is a Lawyers' Game: How to Play to Win
What I'm Hearing
There's more...

Wednesday, January 30, 2008

WGA Strike: We've Got Everything We Need



Negotiate Me, Baby

Unofficial talks continue under media blackout.

The WGA gets stronger every day.

The Screen Actors Guild is firmly on the writers side. Not only on the side of the writers, but getting ready to stage their own walkout in June.

Either this settles quickly, or kiss the Academy Awards goodbye, kiss the up-fronts goodbye, kiss pilot season goodbye (it's pretty much gone at this point anyway), and if SAG goes on strike, kiss Fall 2008 goodbye as well.

At some point, you can kiss goodbye a whole bunch of studio executives, 'cause they're going to get thrown out on their ass by Wall Street, as studio stock prices continue to crater.

Here's SAG's position (posted from United Hollywood):

Letter to SAG Members -- Weaknesses in the DGA Deal

This letter was just sent out to SAG members by Doug Allen (Executive Director and Chief Negotiator) and Allen Rosenberg (President). Emphases in red are from us at UH -- LK.

Dear SAG Member:

Everyone hopes the WGA strike will end with a fair deal for the writers. There has been much speculation about the impact on the WGA strike of the tentative agreement between the Directors Guild of America (DGA) and the employers' representative, the Alliance of Motion Picture and Television Producers (AMPTP). Some have rushed to anoint their deal as the “solution” for the entertainment industry. We believe that assessment is premature.

All we know of the deal are the general terms described in a joint AMPTP/DGA press release. That press release leaves many important questions unanswered. Apparently, many elements of this deal remain unresolved and/or have not been reduced to writing.

The DGA press release suggests progress in some areas, but until the details are known, that is only speculation. Several examples: The formula for new media “electronic sell through (paid downloads or EST)” is based on the higher distributor’s gross revenues, rather than producer’s gross revenues, but the definition of distributor’s gross is vague and not sufficient to protect against manipulation by the employers. Also, information regarding employer “deals and data” will be available to the DGA to monitor distributor’s gross and paid downloads on the Internet, but the press release does not detail what data, who provides the data, and what happens if the data is not provided. The devil is in the details. In the tri-guild audits under the current guilds’ collective bargaining agreements (including the DGA’s), for example, some audits are still open after eight years, because of problems with enforcement under current contract language.

Some have suggested that the new DGA deal contains a “fair market value” test for revenues included in the new media residuals calculation, to protect against self-dealing when one part of a conglomerate sells new media content to another part of the conglomerate at an unfair, low price in order to reduce residuals. We hope this is true, but the press release does not use “arms-length transaction” or “fair market value test” language, and says only, “If our exhibitor or retailer is part of the producer’s corporate family, (DGA has) improved provisions for challenging any suspect transactions.” This language could mean anything, and certainly does not guarantee against self-dealing by media conglomerates to hurt creative talent.

Fair market value and distributor’s gross are two issues that the AMPTP demanded that the WGA take off the table, along with four other items, which resulted in talks breaking off in December. Now after prolonging the strike for another month, the AMPTP has negotiated these two issues with the DGA.

That is the good news. There are also even more serious problems with other provisions described in the DGA press release, particularly those involving new media. For example, why are residuals for electronic sell-through (paid downloads or EST) for directors based on their lower DVD formula (.3%) rather than the higher pay TV formula (1.2%) in their current agreement? All three guilds – SAG, WGA, and DGA – filed for arbitration to overturn management’s attempt to impose the DVD formula for residuals on the calculation of residuals for downloads under the current agreement. The DGA stated in their arbitration filings that payment of the lower amount is a violation of the collective bargaining agreement and the proper residual formula is the higher pay TV percentage. The concession by the DGA in the new deal, to use the formula that management improperly imposed under the current agreement, is an AMPTP roll-back. The new agreed-upon percentages for television (.7%) or feature films (.65%) are much lower in the DGA deal than the percentage that the DGA claims is appropriate in its arbitration (1.2%). And these “increases”, which are based on the discredited DVD formula, do not increase residuals on the sale of DVD’s, but only apply to downloads; despite the fact that DVD’s will generate billions in revenue to the studios and networks for years to come.

The very high thresholds in the DGA deal for full jurisdiction for made for new media content may well incentivize non-union work below the threshold amounts ($15, 000/minute, $300,000/program, $500,000/series, whichever is lower). What will stop the industry from making cheap, non-union pilots at below $300,000 per episode, for testing first on the Internet before the productions migrate to broadcast or basic cable?

Your Guild has signed 210 Internet producers to SAG contracts in the past two years and only seven of them (or 3%) would fall inside the high DGA jurisdictional thresholds. We have worked hard, just as we do with low budget features, to capture this Internet work and to make sure it is done union. This DGA proposal appears to abandon jurisdiction over a huge swath of actual Internet productions, which we currently cover.

This deal gingerly addresses certain issues now, with the apparent hope that in three years or more, revenues will grow and the agreement can be improved to capture more of it. Bargaining history in the entertainment industry, however, teaches that it is much harder to get a fair share of revenue after management puts it in their pockets for years. Residual compensation should be based on a fair share of revenue generated by covered content from the first dollar. Rather than a “percentage of revenue, payment from first dollar” approach to residuals, the DGA deal instead provides for a 17 day window for free streaming of television programs over the Internet without compensation (24 days for the program’s first season). The deal also allows a one year buy-out of $1200 for Internet use v. $20,000 for one re-run on broadcast television.

For these specific reasons, and because so much of the new DGA/AMPTP deal is unknown, no one should assume this new deal is a template for anyone else, certainly not for actors. It is up to the leadership and membership of the DGA to decide if their new deal with the studios and networks is acceptable, but whatever they decide, their decision will not determine what will be satisfactory for the leadership and membership of Screen Actors Guild. Each guild must act in the best interest of its own membership, including rejecting management-imposed “pattern bargaining.”

In solidarity,

Alan Rosenberg, President
Doug Allen, Executive Director and Chief Negotiator
The studios continue to think they can own the internet.

They can not.

Unless they give everyone a fair deal, this strike will last.

And last.

And last.

And last.

It will last for years, if that is what it takes. With SAG joining the WGA.

No kidding. No fooling around. Shut everything down.

PS. If you didn't get the joke of the video, beyond the obvious, it is this...

There is financing waiting in the wings. The studios have screwed up. People like myself are buying cinema grade cameras and going out to shoot our own Academy grade movies.

Fuck the studios.

When it comes time to distribute "What's Your Pattern?" or "Guru Trap", there will be means of financing available to me which does not involve the studio system, and which leaves me as a writer/director, with ownership, not sucking studio tit begging them to give me 1.2% of 20%, i.e. .3% after they take their costs and get creative with the numbers and be thankful. Hell no.

Some writer/directors are already doing 25-50% first-dollar deals with Wall Street or Silicon Valley money and they retain creative control. Seriously.

The studios could have been in on all that. But those bastards got greedy and tried to own everything. They thought we didn't have alternatives. Pigs.

By the time they wake up, ownership will have moved where it belongs -- to the creative forces who invent story and bring it to life. Writers, directors, actors, editors, cinematographers, musicians, and the rest of the creative players.

The studios can go play with themselves in their executive bathrooms.
There's more...

Friday, January 18, 2008

WGA Strike: The Directors Guild of America Makes a Deal


Joss Whedon & Jaime Paglia. Steps of Harvard Lampoon, Cambridge, MA. Dec, 2007.
photo Brad Searles. Click for LARGE image.


A Deal is Stuck. Did the Directors Sell Out?

The DGA has a history of being rolled.

The infamous DVD rate. The Directors Guild fell for that bullshit.

They've been on strike precisely once. For five minutes.

Yeah, they're tough guys, those directors. Balls of, um, well, actually, they pretty much have no balls. They tend to roll over pretty easily.

But this time, even the DGA had to know they had leverage, what with the writers out on strike since November, the Golden Globes reduced to a fracking news show that cost NBC millions, the Oscars breathing down everyone's neck, not to mention the Upfronts with $25 Billion Fucking Dollars and the whole 2008 season on the line, plus, oh yeah, the ACTORS set to strike in June if this isn't settled by then.

A blind man whose dog is deaf with a busted cane would have leverage.

The DGA negoiations took longer than anyone thought they would.

They took longer than hoped.

They took longer than rumored.

And then they just fucking dragged on, over what? New media, baby. 'Cause that's what the whole strike's about.

But now it's done.

In a moment, I'll lay the terms of the DGA deal on you. And then some commentary from some WGA strike captains, followed by my thoughts.

But first, a caution.

There is a time to break heads and bust balls. This isn't it.

This is a time to move slowly and carefully, to think things through. If you are a member of the WGA, there's no rush. The longer you wait, the more leverage you'll have. The point of this whole kurflunkle, is to get the best possible contract.

We will not get less than the DGA deal. That's how pattern bargaining works. But the needs of the Writers Guild are different from the needs of the Directors Guild. Over the next few days, the negotiating committee and lawyers will break down the DGA proposal, line by line and booby trap by trick wording, figuring out precisely what it means for the Guild.

If it's a good contract, we can take it (perhaps with a little more in it for forms' sake.) If it isn't, then we stay out until we get what's fair.

Right now, some people likely want to take any contract, just to go back to work. Mistake. We haven't come this far to settle for shit. We're here to get a fair deal on the future of our profession. Anything less, we stay out.

Enough from me. To read the full posts, make sure to click through.

Here's the WGA announcement:

United Hollywood

DGA Official Announcement

We're working on analysis now, as is the WGA and pretty much everyone else in town. Here's the DGA's statement:

DGA AND AMPTP REACH TENTATIVE AGREEMENT
ON TERMS OF NEW CONTRACT

DGA Gains Solid Wage Increases with No Rollbacks Plus Precedent-Setting Jurisdiction Over New-Media and a Doubling of EST Residuals Rate

LOS ANGELES – The Directors Guild of America (DGA) announced today that it has concluded a tentative agreement on the terms of a new 3-year collective bargaining agreement with the Alliance of Motion Picture and Television Producers (AMPTP).

Highlights of the new agreement include:

Increases both wages and residual bases for each year of the contract.

Establishes DGA jurisdiction over programs produced for distribution on the Internet.

Establishes new residuals formula for paid Internet downloads (electronic sell-through) that essentially doubles the rate currently paid by employers.


Establishes residual rates for ad-supported streaming and use of clips on the Internet.

"Two words describe this agreement - groundbreaking and substantial," said Gil Cates, chair of the DGA's Negotiations Committee, in announcing the terms of the new agreement. "The gains in this contract for directors and their teams are extraordinary – and there are no rollbacks of any kind."

Formal negotiations between the DGA's 50-member Negotiations Committee and the AMPTP began Saturday, January 12, and were concluded today. Talks were led by Cates and DGA National Executive Director Jay D. Roth. They were preceded by months of informal discussions and nearly two years of preparation and research by Guild staff and consultants.

"This was a very difficult negotiation that required real give and take on both sides," said DGA president Michael Apted. "Nonetheless, we managed to produce an agreement that enshrines the two fundamental principles we regard as absolutely crucial to any employment and compensation agreement in this digital age: First, jurisdiction is essential. Without secure jurisdiction over new-media production—both derivative and original—compensation formulas are meaningless. Second, the Internet is not free. We must receive fair compensation for the use and reuse of our work on the Internet, whether it was originally created for other media platforms or expressly for online distribution."

The agreement includes the following gains in New Media:

· Jurisdiction: The new agreement ensures that programming produced for the Internet (both original and derivative) will be directed by DGA members and their teams. The only exceptions are low-budget original shows on which production costs are less than $15,000 per minute, $300,000 per program, or $500,000 per series—whichever is lowest.

· Electronic Sell-Through: EST is the paid download of features and TV programming. The agreement more than doubles the EST residual for television and increases the feature film residual by 80% over the rate currently paid by the employers.

Specifically, the EST residual rates will be .70% for television downloads and .65% for film downloads, above a certain number of units downloaded. Below that, residuals will be based on formula employers currently pay.

Payments for EST will be based on distributor's gross, which is the amount received by the entity responsible for distributing the film or television program on the Internet. Having distributor's gross as the residuals basis was a key point in our negotiations.

The companies are now contractually obligated to give us unfettered access to their deals and data. This access is new and unprecedented and creates a transparency that has never existed before. Additionally, if the exhibitor or retailer is part of the producer's corporate family, we have improved provisions for challenging any suspect transactions.

· Ad-Supported Streaming: After an initial 17-day window for free promotional streaming of Internet programs, companies must pay 3% of the residual base (approximately $600 for network prime time 1-hour drama) for 26 weeks of streaming. They can continue to stream for an additional 26-week period by paying an additional 3% -- or a total of $1,200 for one year's worth of streaming. (During a program's first season, the 17-day window is expanded to 24 days to help build audience.)

· Sunset Provision: Allows both sides to revisit new media when agreement expires.

"Our fundamental goal in these negotiations was to protect our interests in the present while laying the groundwork for a future whose outlines are not yet clear," said Cates. "We knew that gaining jurisdiction over new-media production and winning fair compensation for the reuse of our work on the Internet were the key issues for setting a framework for the future, but we also had to secure real gains for our members in today's world."

The new tentative agreement includes the following:

Annual wage increases of 3% for primetime dramatic shows and daytime serials and 3.5% for all other covered programming.

Outsized increase in director's compensation on high-budget basic cable for series in the second and subsequent seasons.

Annual residual increases of 3% for primetime shows and 3.5% for all other covered programming.

Specific advances that pertain to members of the director's team.

PLEASE SEE FACT SHEET BELOW FOR MORE DETAILS

Details of the new agreement will be submitted to the Guild's National Board for approval at its regularly scheduled meeting on Saturday, January 26, 2008. The DGA's current contracts expire on June 30, 2008.

There's more...
Here's commentary:
United Hollywood

First Glance at the Deal Summary

Before we begin, here's a caveat: WE ARE NOT LAWYERS. WE ARE NOT BUSINESS AFFAIRS EXECS. WE ARE NOT PROFESSIONAL NEGOTIATORS.

We're a group of volunteer WGA strike captains, and we're posting our reactions to the DGA deal summary that was released today. These are our thoughts alone. They are not official, they don't reflect the WGA's opinion, and frankly, they will probably include a few mistakes.

Which brings us to our second caveat: The DGA deal summary is just that, a summary. It's not the final comprehensive contract. That document, we've been told, is still being drafted by the DGA. So the unclear items in the summary will remain so until the DGA releases the contract.

Since the conversation is raging already, we want to weigh in with our preliminary thoughts. Caveats in mind, here we go:

Issues of Wage Increase, Residual Increase and Healthcare
From what we can see in the summary, there are no rollbacks and some decent increases. As rollbacks on just about everything were such a big part of the congloms' proposal to the WGA, we are, cautiously, optimistic here.

Jurisdiction on Internet Productions
The good: Content that is derivative of something already covered would likewise be covered. In other words, mobisodes, webisodes, whatever-isodes based on something that's already a series or a movie are automatically covered, no matter what the budget.

The bad: We can't tell from the deal summary language if that includes the WGA concept of "separated rights." And there are few concepts more important to writers than separated rights. When you create a character, you have merchandising, sequel and other exploitation rights to that character. Those rights can be a very important source of income -- just ask the creators of a character named Captain Jack Sparrow.

Original Internet-first content
The good: there's coverage for productions costing $15,000/minute, when before there was no coverage at all.

The bad: No minimums are mentioned. We don't know for sure, but that could mean the DGA didn't negotiate any. Also, no mention of separated rights in the summary for Internet-first.

Here is a nightmare scenario: Networks start making inexpensive pilots with a budget of $299,000 and put them up on the Internet (on say, Hulu) to gauge their popularity. It's bargain-basement R&D. If a pilot hits, it gets aired on conventional TV, but pays no residuals, contributes no health & pension, provides no separated rights... provides no protections at all. Fifty years of hard-fought creator rights would vanish.

The ambiguous: Regarding coverage of original content below $300,000 per episode, the summary says: "Original content below the threshold will be covered when a DGA member is employed in the production." That language is unclear. If a single DGA member is employed in a sub-$300,000 production, is the whole production covered (including btl crew)? Or just the DGA member? If it's the whole production, that's a "good." But if it's just one person? That's a "bad."

Electronic Sell-Through (aka downloads)
For the first 100,000 downloads of a TV show, the payment is the DVD rate: 0.3%. After the first 100,000, it rises to .7%

For features, the rate is 0.3% for the first 50,000 downloads and 0.65% thereafter.

The good: It's more than twice what we had before.

The bad: What we had before was based on the miserable DVD formula. WGA, SAG and DGA had all agreed that that number really should be 1.2%, and the unions have actually sued the congloms over it, claiming that the use of the DVD formula for downloads is a misinterpretation of their respective MBAs.

So the 0.7% and 0.65% numbers are still terribly low. In addition, many downloads will not reach the 100,000 or 50,000 threshold, and will generate only the abysmal 0.3%.

It's frustrating to us that the DGA couldn't increase that number out of the DVD range. The DVD formula was based on the notion that "home video" meant a bulky plastic VHS tapes with enormous manufacturing and transportation costs. Those costs decreased dramatically over the years. But no increase in residuals. They decreased dramatically again with birth of DVDs. (You can slip them under a door!) But no increase in residuals. With downloads, the manufacturing cost is exactly zero dollars. And terabytes of storage are getting cheaper by the hour. But we still can't improve that DVD formula? Really?

Distributor's Gross
Payments for EST and, we assume, downloads will be based on distributor's gross, which is much better than producer's gross.

The good: This is what the WGA was asking for, and up until now, the congloms said it was a non-starter.

The bad: How will the accounting be kept transparent? The deal summary doesn't provide any guidance. Until we know how the DGA plans to guarantee that the distributor's gross is an accurate number, we can't know if this is meaningful. ("Net profit" points, anyone?)

Ad-Supported Streaming
For the first 17-24 days, no residual payments at all. After that first run, $600 for six months, up to $1200 for the first year of unlimited streaming. After the first year, 2% of distributor's gross.

The good: 2% of distributor's gross is a meaningful number, again with the caveat that the accounting has to be transparent.

The bad: In the near future -- and in some cases, the present -- rerunning television shows on the Internet will replace conventional reruns. This structure, as described in the summary, to our eyes appears to be the end of television residuals. Whereas a primetime network rerun would be worth $20,000, unlimited streaming on the Internet would be worth only $1200, assuming the episode is kept available for an entire year.

Now, as the companies point out, the current Internet streaming market cannot support a residual level that conventional TV can. It may in the near future, in the distant future, or never. So that's why it seems to us (as the WGA NegComm has said in the past) that the best strategy here is to grant the writer a percentage of real revenue. That is not only the best way to fairly compensate writers, but also a hedge for the companies. If and when the streaming market takes off, flat fees for reuse will be egregiously unfair. The percentage model could, in time, make up for the loss of TV residuals as advertising moves solidly to the Internet.

In years two through infinity, 2% of distributors gross is a meaningful formula. But 2% of what? Even if an episode is kept online for more than one year (and who's to say it would), the demand to view it will be minimal. After a year, the episode will likely be available on a DVD set, and has probably been available as a paid download for some time. The minimal number of streams will mean a minimal ad rate. So enjoy your 2%, writer.

If the ad revenue even in the first year of streaming turns out to be negligible, then giving writers a percentage is insurance that the congloms won't have to overpay. But if something takes off and becomes wildly successful, then a percentage-of-revenue model would reward the writer appropriately.

There's more...
My immediate concerns:

1. The streaming rate is a deal breaker.

$1200 bucks for a year of unlimited downloads, after 17 to 24 free days? Vs. $20,000 for one rerun on network television.

Yeah, right. And within six months, there will BE no reruns on network television. EVERY rerun will be on the internet, and just like that, kiss braces and health benefits and every other damn thing goodbye.

It's still them trying to take over the internet for nothing. Fuck that.

2. Too many loopholes, from the nightmare scenario, to the DVD rate being too low (which isn't a loophole, but is an insult.)

3. More will surface when the full contract does.

This is not an acceptable contract for writers in my initial read, based completely on the internet land grab. Turn that from a flat fee into 2% of Distributor's Gross (which is the deal after the first year anyway), and the rest of this can be worked out.

What the AMPTP has got to understand is, the writers are willing to stay out the next year if that's what it takes to get a fair deal. No kidding. REALLY no kidding.

And come June, the actors -- 90% of whom are unemployed anyway (as actors; they have day jobs) will happily go on strike and shut down all production everywhere, as the stock prices of all six studios falls straight into the crapper.

Strike. Strike. Strike.

From the GNB Union Desk, this is Jesse Wendel, picket sign raised high.

PS. So no, the Directors Guild didn't sell out. Not precisely.

But they didn't negotiate as if their future depended on it either. They didn't negotiate as if they had genuine leverage, and they sure as shit didn't ever consider pushing these studio mother-fuckers to the goddamn wall.

They negotiated like insiders. Like part of the system. Like partners with management. Like elegant fellows who are willing to give up actual power, in exchange for not undergoing the indignity of having to walk around in circles out in the rain and the snow and the sun holding a sign. Because they're like, above all that. They're Directors.

Which is a shame. Because if the Directors Guild had shown some damn stones, between the writers, the directors, and the actors, we could have broken the studios major.

We still can... between the writers and the actors, that's all the true strength we need. 'Cause ain't no one going to work without a script and someone to act it.
There's more...

Friday, January 11, 2008

WGA Strike: Scab of the Week


Matt Taibbi. file photo WNYC New York Public Radio, April 11, 2006.

Matt Taibbi is a Punk

I don't care that Taibbi made fun of a dying Pope.

Just shows he has no class.

I've read his stuff. He can't write comedy.

Lower Manhattanite can write rings around Taibbi's tight-ass.

Which shouldn't matter; Taibbi writes for Rolling Stone, not Mad Magazine. Except Taibbi fancies himself funny and satirical.

You know what isn't funny?

Crossing a picket line against striking writers.

Taibbi appeared on Comedy Central's The Colbert Report this past Wednesday. (No I'm not linking. We're on strike.)

But here are the late night schedules.

Notice how the struck shows don't dare tell you who's appearing until after they've appeared?

That's because when people find how someone's going on, damn near EVERYONE calls and tells them what idiots they are.

Mostly they back out. Because who wants their mother, boy or girlfriend, neighbors, and everyone they care about calling them up:

Mom: Hey, dumb ass... what are you doing? This family doesn't cross picket lines. I didn't raise you to be a fool. And I did not work my ass off for 27 years for you to act retarded. Now you get on the phone right now. You call Conan back and tell them no son of mine is doing a struck show, you hear me boy?

Dumb Ass: Yes Mom, I hear you.

Mom: You better. And then get your sorry miserable, dumb ass home, because I am going to climb high up on a stool where I can reach you. Then I am going to slap you so hard son, what little brains you have left are going to come right out your eyeballs and spill down the front of your Armani shirt. Who came up with this cluster-fuck of an idea anyway?! I know it wasn't you.

Dumb Ass: It was my agent, Mom.

Mom: You mean, your ex-agent?

Dumb Ass: But Mom...

Mom: Anyone dumb enough to have a man as handsome as you cross a picket-line and ruin your damn career, when anyone with only half the brains God gave a Golden Retriever, and the Lord knows that isn't the brightest dog in the world, knows you could be out on the picket-line getting free publicity just bringing donuts to the writers. They're not the swiftest bunch. Give them donuts and you'll be up on YouTube as their friend forever.

She's not your agent any more son; she screwed up. You were born naturally stupid just like your poor Daddy, but your agent we pay 10% to 'cause she's supposed to be smart. And now she's done gone and screwed the pooch.

Dumb Ass: The pooch, Mom?

Mom: It means, I just fired her sorry ass for being behind the times.

Son, you call Conan's people and tell them your Mother said you are not crossing any picket lines. No way, never, no how. Then come straight home. I've got apple pie waiting...

The Colbert Report is being actively picketed.

Taibbi was contacted by the WGA, asked not to go on the show. He ignored his brother and sister writers, went on anyway, and then... wasn't funny. Colbert carried him.

Lame.

Friday night, Taibbi is scheduled to CROSS ANOTHER PICKET LINE to appear on Real Time with Bill Maher.

Taibbi is a fucking punk. It's that simple.

Punks are people that when incoming drops in, can't be counted on to cover their buddies' backs or their own fire zones.

When New York Press editor Jeff Koyen quit rather than take a suspension over running Taibbi's "funny" article mocking the death of a dying Pope, did Taibbi walk out the door with him?

No. He punked out, only to quit just before being forced out the door in a management change.

Punks feel bad. They whine and complain, dodge and weave. Most of all, they come up with excuses for not doing what's right.

There's another word for punk...

Coward.

Here's another...

Opportunist.

My personal favorite...

Stupid motherfucker.

Taibbi -- You've just made clear to every Guild writer, you know you lack the talent to write for movies and television. 'Cause if you thought there was the slightest chance you had a screenplay in you, you would never cross a Writers Guild of America picket.

WGA writer's don't forgive scabs -- or those who help them by crossing picket lines.

Ya no-talent un-funny punk.
There's more...

Tuesday, January 1, 2008

WGA Strike: World Wide Pants Makes Deal

Speechless #27


Speechless #28


Go Letterman Go!

The WGA made a full deal with World Wide Pants, Dave Letterman's company.

The deal INCLUDED the entire MBA. Everything the the WGA had on the table -- where the AMPTP left it when they walked out 25 days ago -- has now been negotiated fully, closed and signed with 'Pants.

Done. Game over. (For WWP. Their writers -- and only their writers -- are returning to work.)

What great, amazing news.

United Hollywood (Howard A. Rodman, member of the WGA Board and founder of the Guild's independent film writers committee)

Top 10 Reasons Why The Worldwide Pants Deal is a Good Idea

10. The AMPTP says that we're too crazy, too ideological, too amateurish to make a deal, and this lets us say, oh yeah?

9. The Networks That Are Not CBS will be hard put to justify to their advertisers and stockholders why they're letting the competition have a real late-night show while they go forth with writerless efforts. (As The Canadian Press put it yesterday, "Jay Leno, Conan O'Brien, Jimmy Kimmel and Jon Stewart all plan returns to late-night television over the next two weeks, but aside from their familiar faces, viewers may not recognize much.")

8. And despite what some will say, that's genuine pressure. Yes, the conglomerates have deep pockets. But they do have to answer to the folks who pay the bills.

7. Because it's not just a plain vanilla interim deal: this is a deal we can use as a model, with cherries on top.

6. Cherries, in this case, meaning that the Letterman deal is the full MBA, complete with the New Media proposals we couldn't get the other side to move on at the Big Table. This shows our proposals are affordable. And, perhaps best of all, Worldwide Pants is taking on the liability of our contract provisions, including not only the payment terms, but also the backstop of the fair market valuation test under the MBA.

5. Although this will be very hard on Leno, Conan, Kimmel and other late-night Guild writers, the wedge that it drives between the networks is deeper and sharper than the wedge it drives between writers. While the companies understand ROI, only we understand solidarity.

4. Go re-read number 10.

3. Like the waiver for the SAG awards, it lets people know that, when we are able to, we honor those who honor us.

2. Because in 1988, Letterman called management "money-grubbing scum." Out loud. In public.

1. Worldwide Pants has a better logo than the AMPTP.

On a more serious note, though: we should all remember what writers gave up in 1960 so that all writers who came after them -- meaning us -- could have residuals. In order to make that deal, they gave up the rights to residuals for everything they had written prior to 1960. The sacrifice they made for the future is inspiring, and humbling in the best possible sense.
Today is the first day of 2008.

Today it has been twenty-five days since the AMPTP walked out of negotiations.

Welcome to the most important labor action of the new century.

This fight is dog-shit simple.

Will the bullies (studios) get away with stealing lunch money from the geeks (writers, actors, and directors) forever and ever, amen... or not?

At stake is control of the internet.

Whom do you want in charge?

Six big studios run by bullies?

Or middle-class folks with kids in schools and bills to pay?

Folks like you and I who genuinely give a damn about families, the war, and taking care of people. Not to mention the occasional fart joke, musical, or a musical with a fart joke. (Blazing Saddles, anyone?)

How long is our own Lower Manhattanite -- a Guild Writer -- really willing to wait?

Let's ask writers on the picket line...
  • What are you striking for?
  • What's the hardest part of striking?
  • How long are you willing to wait?
There's more...

Wednesday, December 26, 2007

WGA Strike: 19 Days Since the AMPTP Walked Out

Speechless


A Working Writer: Dawn Dekeyser

There's more...

Saturday, December 15, 2007

Want Some Swag?


Katherine Heigl in WGA Official Strike Shirt. Click for large version.
photo from Writers Strike Swag

Support the Writers -- Get Writer's Strike Swag

All profits are donated to the WGA Union Solidarity Fund.

I'm wearing that shirt as I write this.

Well, not that actual shirt. *sighs* But the same shirt. People really like it.

They have other shirts as well. Quick shipping. PayPal.

Go now to http://www.strikeswag.com/ and order! Yes, you.

They even have a VIRTUAL PICKET LINE, so once you're all decked out in your shirt, you can take a photo and they'll post it. Then you can link up in one of our comment threads about the strike. How 'bout them apples?!

Do not pass go. Do not collect $200.

Order your Strike Swag and help the WGA, and maybe Katherine Heigl will give you a back rub while both of you are wearing your official Strike Shirts...

That'll make someone go BOOM. (Speechless. Tim Robbins.)

There's more...

Tuesday, December 11, 2007

WGA Strike: Chris Lehane Fired By Education Union



LA Education SEIU Local 99 has fired Chris Lehane from a consulting contract.

Yesterday in WGA Strike: AMPTP Screwing All Unions I wrote:

There are consequences for being a scab.

One of them is that NO ONE, ever, ever, ever, EVER, fucking EVER works with you again. You're fucking DEAD to us now.

That's how you enforce Union discipline. Cross a picket line as a member of the Union, fight against a union, you're fucking through with that union. This guy claims to be a progressive, but he's working with the goddamn studios to try and bust the WGA?

He needs to be made an example of. No Democratic organization, no one on our side of the aisle gets to EVER use him or his company again, even to clean up after a botched race for dog-catcher. I swear by the sacred ovaries of PenĂ©lopĂȘ, we need to bring this mother-fracker down.
It has started.

Jane Hamsher at Firedoglake has the story.
Firedoglake

"By the end of the week, I believe Chris Lehane will have no union clients because of his work for the AMPTP," says SEIU President Andy Stern, who confirms that all Change to Win Unions are severing ties with Lehane. "His days are numbered in the labor movement."

The decision came after Lehane began consulting for AMPTP, who walked away from the negotiating table with the WGA on Friday insisting that they agree to cross the picket lines of other unions before they would return to the talks. It was an overt union-busting move meant to drive a wedge between the WGA and SAG, who have been supportive of the writers and whose contract with the AMPTP is up for renewal in June. Change to Win unions include the Teamsters, Laborers, SEIU, Carpenters & Joiners, United Farm Workers, Food and Commercial Workers, and UNITE HERE.

You can send an email to the network executives in charge of your favorite shows and tell them to return to the negotiating table here.
Alec Baldwin would have had the writers go back to work.

When someone fucks with you, you kick them in the balls, hit them in the throat, or just beat them silly till they're down on the ground. Then you beat them more till they learn, never, ever, ever to fuck with you or your friends again.

And I'm not talking in metaphor. Or at least, not only talking in metaphor.

Chris Lehane is about to have his entire career with liberal and progressive causes destroyed forever. Because he fucked with us, and we're not the Democrats he's used to scamming. We're the ones from the Netroots; too many of us know full well what it is to wash blood off after work.

He's fucked with the wrong Democrats. He's going down. If nothing else, as an object lesson to others as to what happens when you cross the Unions.

Personally, I see no reason for him even to get his shirt mussed, let alone actually bloody. He's the kind of asshole for whom money and status is everything. He has no actual ethics, and knows nothing of what it is to have someone's back. Time to rip ALL of his status and money away, leaving him desperately blowing Republican goats to survive.

Should take less than a month for every Democratic client he has to fire him.

Buh-bye, scab.
There's more...

Monday, December 10, 2007

WGA Strike: AMPTP Screwing All Unions



I ate breakfast at my favorite joint this morning, wearing my WGAw Strike shirt.

The waitress was on our side after I'd talked maybe two minutes. Two and a half cents. It's only fair.

But that isn't what I want to write about today.

Two issues, no, three.

First, let's talk more about why Chris Lehane is a scab.

United Hollywood

As of last week, the AMPTP retained the powerhouse "crisis management" firm of Fabiani and Lehane (known in political circles as "the Masters of Disaster." )They also have "a reputation for hardball tactics in damage control and inflicting damage on opponents."

This firm has built a reputation and a substantial income largely from Democratic, progressive political causes. A short list of their past employers includes Al Gore, Bill and Hillary Clinton, Michael Moore/Miramax (for Fahrenheit 9/11 and Sicko), and my personal favorite, the Screen Actors Guild. Founding partner Chris Lehane is currently a consultant for the Californians for Fair Election Reform, a major Democratic group, among other things.

My DC lobbyist friends tell me that for emergency “crisis management,” firms like Fabiani & Lehane charge as much as $100,000 dollars a month. But the AMPTP is also paying Steve Schmidt, a veteran Republican-leaning PR guru. He could easily cost another $100,000 a month.

My concern is this: no one hires crisis management firms at such huge expense if they’re planning on making a fair deal. A fair deal doesn't require hundreds of thousands of dollars of spin to sell. A fair deal is its own good PR.

The WGA hasn’t hired a huge PR firm. We don’t want to “spin” anyone. United Hollywood is an all-volunteer blog, and our PR strategy is simple: we tell the truth.

The truth is, we’re fighting for the future for all working people in Hollywood.

The truth is, new media coverage and internet residuals are vital to the income of writers, directors and actors.

The truth is, the below-the-line unions rely on residuals to fund over half of their pension and health plans, and their rate is tied directly to ours. If we lose, their P&H will likely be decimated.

The truth is, if we don’t get coverage for new media productions, the below the line unions won’t get it either. If we lose, they lose.

This strike is a disaster for the working men and women of California, and many other regions that rely on the entertainment industry for jobs. We didn’t want this strike. And the AMPTP could stop it tomorrow because our proposals are affordable and reasonable.

But instead of making a fair deal with us, they hire Fabiani & Lehane. The proposal gets a snazzy new name, the CEO's take out new ads and tell everyone how great their proposal is. Except that then, they don't give it to us. Remember the second half of the proposal they said we'd have on Tuesday? We still haven’t gotten it. Hard to negotiate without the offer. And it's becoming clear they don't intend to give it to us -- one theory being that they're stalling, looking for an opportunity to walk out of the talks and blame the WGA leadership for it.

It's time for the CEO's to stop playing PR games and get a deal done.

When Fabiani & Lehane worked for SAG in 2002, Lehane said at the time:
“... we believe strongly in the need to preserve the strength of the union and this agreement does that. We both come from liberal, progressive backgrounds, and this union represents working people."
For the record, so does the WGA, which is why SAG is our ally. And yet, right now Chris Lehane is helping the conglomerates try to divide this union internally and orchestrate ways to get us to question our leadership.

In other words, Chris Lehane is union busting.

And since Lehane and his firm have made their fortune – and continue to make it – off of Democratic Party connections and progressive causes, I think the hypocrisy here is pretty appalling.

Below is the contact info for the three frontrunners for the Democratic presidential nomination. Hillary Clinton, who says she supports the writers in this strike, has worked extensively with Fabiani & Lehane. Barack Obama and John Edwards also support the strike, and they work with many of the organizations that Fabiani & Lehane rely on for their business.

Call these 3 candidates, and politely ask them to promise to hold Fabiani & Lehane accountable for what they are doing.

Tell Clinton, Edwards and Obama this:

"As long as Fabiani & Lehane are in the business of union-busting, we want your personal assurance that they will not be in the business of working with Democratic organizations, businesses, politicians or candidates.

A strike is not a business opportunity to make a profit by harming the interests of working men and women."

Hillary Clinton (213) 908-0190 socalhrc@hillaryclinton.com

John Edwards (919) 636-3131 info@johnedwards.com

Barack Obama (866) 675-2008

The AMPTP likes to say that this is all about business. Well, the business of hypocrisy shouldn’t pay.
I think that pretty much handles the issue of Chris "the fucking Scab" Lehane.

There are consequences for being a scab.

One of them is that NO ONE, ever, ever, ever, EVER, fucking EVER works with you again. You're fucking DEAD to us now.

That's how you enforce Union discipline. Cross a picket line as a member of the Union, fight against a union, you're fucking through with that union. This guy claims to be a progressive, but he's working with the goddamn studios to try and bust the WGA?

He needs to be made an example of. No Democratic organization, no one on our side of the aisle gets to EVER use him or his company again, even to clean up after a botched race for dog-catcher. I swear by the sacred ovaries of PenĂ©lopĂȘ, we need to bring this mother-fracker down.

Item the second. It's been clear all week, the Studios have been planning to fuck with us, to build us up, then to pull the rug out. They're toying with the writers' emotions, trying to play divide the writers and turn them against each other, so they can get people to accept a bad deal in the end.

This is NOT going to work. I swear these folks will stay out for a YEAR if that is what it takes to shove this crap up the studio's ass. This is for all the marbles and the longer this lasts, the angrier everyone is getting. No writer is backing down.

As usual, Nikki has all the answers:
Deadline Hollywood

EXCLUSIVE: I wish I had better news about the AMPTP-WGA contract negotiations, but I don't. To sum up, they suck. I took extra time reporting tonight, and some very surprising developments came to light.

For instance, Peter Chernin is privately telling Hollywood that the producers plan to quit the talks any day now. That they have no intention of coming back with another streaming proposal "until we are close". And that they'll only give a better electronic sell-through formula "at the last minute" when a contract with the writers is virtually signed.

These quiet remarks by the Fox/News Corp No. 2 are the complete opposite of what the AMPTP is telling the WGA around the bargaining table.

I'm told Thursday's talks began at 10 AM, and both the WGA and AMPTP had a brief discussion about streaming, made-for-web content pay and jurisdiction, and electronic sell-through. Then one of the negotiators from the network and studio CEOs' side declared, "The DVD formula is good for you, and you should embrace it with open arms."

The bigwigs have even concocted this fiction that they wanted to solve the strike in three intense days of negotiations before Christmas but now they see that's impossible because of the level of mistrust and misunderstanding around the table. My sources tell me the CEOs seem to be looking for any excuse to blame WGA chief negotiator Dave Young specifically for "blowing it".

But the truth is this: the Hollywood moguls have not delivered on their promises. And Chernin's statements make clear they never had any intention of doing so right now. Days are passing, and the AMPTP still hasn't come back with a counter/counter-offer to the WGA's counter-offer to the AMPTP's offer on streaming. Days are passing, and the AMPTP still hasn't come back with the 2nd half of its New Media proposal presumably containing ESTs. Days are passing, and the AMPTP and WGA are still paralyzed on Internet issues, which is why they moved way down their list to the subject of Reality TV jurisdiction. Sure that angered the CEOs who own a network -- and I think it was a giant mistake by the writers' negotiating team to get off New Media and onto that. But it came up because of the AMPTP's stalling tactics, and the two sides had to jawbone about something.

In conclusion, I wouldn't be at all surprised if, as soon as Friday, the AMPTP walks out of the talks with a news release in hand that it's all the WGA's fault.
And sure enough, Nikki was right on the money...
United Hollywood

Moguls Break Off Talks Without Real Offer

As of right now, the Moguls have broken off the talks with a very long, very prepared and very nasty statement. It's also full of half-truths and outright lies.

It clearly took someone some time to write, and a lot of thought has gone into crafting it for maximum potential dissent within the ranks. It's a PR doc, and it's very well-written. You don't create something like this in ten minutes, or even an hour. This kind of thing takes days, especially if a large group of CEO's have to sign off on it.

So they've been planning this for a while. Which doesn't speak to good faith in the negotiation on their side.

One of the sticking points, apparently, was our leadership's refusal to promise they would cross a SAG picket line. It certainly appears that someone is planning for another strike sometime soon. And they want to crush that union, too. Assuming, of course, that they can crush us.

We're going to have more on this soon, but right now, all I can say is: remember that a very, very expensive consultant has orchestrated all of this for precisely one reason -- to win. This isn't about the moguls being "reasonable" or protecting the internet streaming business (that is really so laughable it was almost impossible to type) or any of the things that document talks about.

It's about winning. And they can only win if we let it happen.

Stay strong, we'll have more soon.
Also this...
United Hollywood
This is the letter that was just sent to the membership:

WGA's Response to AMPTP Breaking Off Talks

Today, after three days of discussions, the AMPTP came back to us with a proposal that included a total rejection of our proposal on Internet streaming of December 3.

They are holding to their offer of a $250 fixed residual for unlimited one year streaming after a six-week window of free use. They still insist on the DVD rate for Internet downloads.

They refuse to cover original material made for new media.

This offer was accompanied by an ultimatum: the AMPTP demands we give up several of our proposals, including Fair Market Value (our protection against vertical integration and self-dealing), animation, reality, and, most crucially, any proposal that uses distributor’s gross as a basis for residuals. This would require us to concede most of our Internet proposal as a precondition for continued bargaining. The AMPTP insists we let them do to the Internet what they did to home video.

We received a similar ultimatum through back channels prior to the discussions of November 4. At that time, we were assured that if we took DVD’s off the table, we would get a fair offer on new media issues. That offer never materialized.

We reject the idea of an ultimatum. Although a number of items we have on the table are negotiable, we cannot be forced to bargain with ourselves. The AMPTP has many proposals on the table that are unacceptable to writers, but we have never delivered ultimatums.

As we prepared our counter-offer, at 6:05 p.m., Nick Counter came and said to us, in the mediator’s presence: “We are leaving. When you write us a letter saying you will take all these items off the table, we will reschedule negotiations with you.” Within minutes, the AMPTP had posted a lengthy statement announcing the breakdown of negotiations.

We remain ready and willing to negotiate, no matter how intransigent our bargaining partners are, because the stakes are simply too high. We were prepared to counter their proposal tonight, and when any of them are ready to return to the table, we’re here, ready to make a fair deal.

John F. Bowman
Chairman, WGA Negotiating Committee
Contract 2007
Here's the take away.

The corporations are trying to mind-fuck the writers into accepting a bad deal. Anything less that steely resolve at every step along the picket line, will be met with contempt and a good rogering by these sociopathic fucks.

No blinking, no giving in, no avoiding responsibility. Our intent here is to make these six corporate entities, their principle stockholders and advertisers, and the people running the studios, hurt. Badly. And not blink at all while doing so.

They would strip us, our families, and all future writers, actors, directors, and every other creative guild of our pensions, health benefits, and pay from all future media streams, forever. Without even hesitating. And get their rocks off too.

Our job is to beat them down so hard no corporation EVER fucks with the creatives, ever again. That two hundred years from now, this lesson is still remembered and taught in B schools as:

"Some wars are not worth fighting, some people should never be attacked. The people who invent whole worlds and juggle them as their personal play-toys, while determining our cultural sense of ourselves, are NOT people to fuck with. Ever. They just might decide to write us out of the story. Which in the end, is what happened to the value of the Studios... the Writers jointly started telling new stories about who Producers and Studios were, and lo and behold, the Studios discovered they suddenly Just.Weren't.Needed.Anymore. Took less than a year. The strike ended with the studios begging the writers to come back to work on any terms, an unconditional surrender. The writers said no, and the studios went out of business. Welcome to the internet and direct distribution. Which is how the writers, directors and actors, took back control of their own destinies, and set the stage for a new artistic renaissance."

This vision of the future, will only happen through fighting the bullshit every day, and by not stupidly surrendering anything now. (*waves to Alec Baldwin*)

This matters. It is for the future of modern culture and the right to not have six corporations who don't give a shit about anything that matters, control entertainment for the next hundred years.
There's more...

Thursday, December 6, 2007

WGA Strike: Same Old Same Old


Screenwriter Irving Brecher
Meet Me In St. Louis, Bye Bye Birdie, Marx Brothers At The Circus & Go West, Life of Riley, and more.

The WGA Strike drags on.

Yesterday, the WGA put the Reality writers on the table, demanding to represent the writers who write Reality Television.

As Reality TV is a large part of what the Studios are relying on to get them through the strike, this is akin to threatening to take away the Studio's big gun in any future strike.

"No -- leave my penis alone. I NEED it." "Oh please, we're very GLBT friendly. Here -- go watch Topgun. But only on DVD. Streaming Internet Topgun doesn't pay residuals."

In other news, here is part of why the Studios are fighting so hard against the writers on this new media stuff... because if the writers get the four cent raise per DVD they're asking for -- the 2.5% raise that is 20+ years overdue -- because that same raise will be reflected in the contracts for SAG and DGA and other unions, plus pension fund, health benefits, and other payouts, the actual cost will come to almost 10 times the four cent per DVD sold.

Did I just say, instead of an extra four cents per DVD, the Studios would have to pay an extra almost 40 cents per DVD? Yep. The numbers are all nicely laid out by Digital Media Law in a post first done at Huffington.

Can the Studios afford it? Abso-fucking-lutely. Yes. You betcha. Yes Ma'am. Yep. No kidding, yeah, ya'huh, and that's right! Ice... man.

The total cost per studio per year of this proposed raise for all of the contracts combined -- WGA, DGA AND SAG -- isn't even the cost of ONE middle-of-the-road movie per year, let alone the cost of advertising the movie. It's a no brainier. Which explains of course, why the Studio executives are fighting it so hard.

This video below shows who the executives are fighting against. It's you and me, and every other working stiff. It's the Union...

Who's On The Line



Where do I go to get strike news?

UnitedHollywood.com.
Nikki Finke.

And most importantly, from...

LateShowWritersOnStrike.Com (Who ain't so damn funny.)


Updated 9:15 AM PT:

Holy Shit is Alec Baldwin Fucking Stupid.

Alec Baldwin suggests the writers go back to work and let the negotiations keep going.
Huffington Post

The strike should end now. The writers should go back to work. Continue negotiating, but go back to work. The report in yesterday's New York Times about NBC buying blocks of programming from "outside producers" is a view to our future. Just as MOWs were killed off the networks and original movies became the exclusive realm of the cable broadcasters, one can envision a future where more scripted programming moves to cable. Eventually, HBO and Showtime, et al, may become the place to find the bulk of scripted shows. With these people calling the shots, anything is possible.

In the meantime, the writers, and the other sellers as well, have a different idea they can try. I recall when a popular late night talk show host skewered the head of his own network for a prolonged run, right there on his show. On and on it went and, from what I heard, that network head was apoplectic. These people have bigger egos than even the stars themselves, but without any sense of humor. I want the WGA to set up a website and on that website we can all post stories about every no-talent, idiotic, amoral producer and executive we have ever dealt with. Just like they do to us on shows like Extra and sites like TMZ (owned by Warner Brothers.) Set up a website and tell the entire world, via the internet, your own anecdote about some of the witless boobs you have endured in Hollywood and beyond. The strike will end in a week.
Well, why don't I just fuck your girlfriend, Alec, in a bedroom right off the negotiating room. Really paper thin walls, and a headboard that slams into the wall as she moans and screams and cries out, gasping and calling my name.

Every couple of hours of negotiations we'll take a 30-45 minute break so the two of us can tear one off. She is, multi-orgasmic, right? Oh, don't worry; she will be. And during negotiations Alec, with you sitting over there with the Studio producers, she and I'll sit next to each other, almost in each other's laps, my hand dipping out of your sight under the table and she's wearing that oh so so short, short skirt. And you know she never wears panties Alex, as she and I smile at each other, barely even aware you're in the damn room.

This can go on for weeks as the lawyers negotiate.

What are we negotiating? Her sexual fidelity with you.

My hand out of sight, moving back and forth slowly, oh so slowly as her breathing deepens right there in the room right across the fucking table from you you stupid schmuck. Sometimes... Sometimes as she comes, gasping right there at the negotiating table, she'll look up and see you hopelessly watching her straight in the eye... and the bitch smiles. Because you know -- all this is just for Promotional Purposes.

Are you starting to get it Alec?

Every writer, every other major actor at least has the decency to shut the hell up if they're not with us, and everyone I have any respect for IS with us. Including your boss, Tina Fey.

So long as we're negotiating your girl friend's sexual fidelity, I don't ever, ever, EVER need to stop fucking her. Fucking and getting her off, in front of you. Three, four, five, eight times a day Alex, plus those extra little special moments where I make her breathe extra deep in the main room. Because as long as you're talking, you're not doing anything. So your girlfriend is mine.

As for your genuinely dumb-shit idea about insulting the executives of the Studios, didn't yelling at your daughter teach you ANYTHING?

Who do you think you are? Triumph, the Insult Comic Dog? Whose latest album is called, "Come Poop With Me!" (NSFW)

What are you, twelve?

Everything which has happened so far has only happened because the writers are behaving like grown-ups, asking for what is obviously a fair deal, and the Studio producers are behaving like spoiled 12 year-olds, throwing temper tantrums and refusing to share ANY of the pie with their brother and sister, when they didn't even bake the pie, pick the apples, peel the apples, or plant the tree. In fact, the producers can't even tell which kind of apple tastes best -- all pies are pretty much the same to them, but it doesn't stop them from trying to prevent anyone else from having a taste.

You, Alec, are acting just like the damn producers. Dumb. And disrespectful of the writers who write the lines you speak on the show that pays your salary.

Hey -- I've got an idea. Since you don't know what the fuck you're talking about, how about till the writers pick up their pencils again, what about you become...

There's more...