Showing posts with label gas price. Show all posts
Showing posts with label gas price. Show all posts

Wednesday, December 3, 2008

What Condition Our Condition Is In

(Photoillustration: "Big Red Letters on a Dead End Sign" by Evan Robinson, Group News Blog)

Here We Are

It's been seven months since I lasted addressed our condition. In the meantime we've finished a two-year campaign and election, with historic results. Those of you in America have survived the Thanksgiving Holiday (most of you), although not everyone overseas did, and there is much wailing and gnashing of teeth over Black Friday, even as sales seem to be going better than many feared.

So let's take a look at a few other elements of our condition...

That Devil's Madness -- War

Mumbai is on our minds. Asymmetric warfare is as much about media coverage as it is about inflicting military defeat, and it was genius (twisted, evil genius) to stage the attack during American Thanksgiving when much of the country is already in front of the television for traditional parades, specials, and both college and professional football.

While debate rages about the identity and backers of the Mumbai attacks, the NY Daily News says that as few as 10 attackers were involved:

The 60-hour Mumbai terror spree that killed at least 174 people was the brutal handiwork of just 10 Islamic militants who wanted to create a 9/11-caliber catastrophe, officials said Saturday.

The Guardian reports that the only surviving attacker, Pakistani Azam Amir Kasab, says the militants trained in Kashmir for five months:

Kasab reportedly said the mastermind of the plot briefed the militants to "target whites, preferably Americans and British".

He said the militants, who were highly trained in marine assault, had arrived in the city by boat. They planned to blow up the Taj Mahal Palace hotel after first executing British and American tourists and then taking hostages.

Police sources said Kasab told officers that he and his fellow terrorists trained in Pakistan-occupied Kashmir for five months before taking a month off before the attacks, the Daily Mail reported.

They left an isolated beach in Karachi for Mumbai on November 21 and were each given eight hand grenades, an AK-47 rifle, an automatic pistol and ammunition.

The Sidney Morning Herald reports that the targets were extensively scouted and attackers prepared with CQB training and memorisation of the target layouts. They hoped to kill more people than the 9/11 attacks:

The terrorist gang, thought to number as few as 10 gunmen, had planned to kill 5000 people and destroy the iconic Taj Mahal Palace hotel and the stock exchange. In the end, their murderous toll was closer to 200, and left the Taj Mahal and the Tident-Oberoi hotel badly charred and damaged.

Kasab had months of training before the attack where he was instructed in the use of military weapons and explosives. He and his fellow attackers, aged between 18 and 28, were also drilled in close quarter combat.

An Australian witness, Ray Lacey, who saw the attackers in the foyer of the Taj Mahal, said they were highly disciplined and did not waste bullets.

Kasab told investigators they were instructed to conserve their ammunition so they could sustain their attack for as long as possible. "I have done right. I have no regrets."

Kasab told interrogators that most of the volunteers for the suicide mission spoke Punjabi. They were given false identities and were discouraged from interacting with each other beyond what was barely necessary.

Regardless of the origin and backing of the attackers, Mumbai shows a new sophistication in media use, plotting attacks of a new and different kind apparently specifically to take advantage of American media viewing patterns: the timing of the attack, the sophistication of the targeting and planned duration of the attack, even down to one of the attackers being captured and talking freely to the media afterward.

As with most 4GW, the damage done was hugely disproportionate to the investment required by the attackers. The 9/11 attacks cost less than $500,000 to carry out, and bore a ginormous price tag. Since half of that $500,000 was in-US expenses and these attackers staged and trained in Kashmir, I wouldn't be surprised to find out that hte cost of putting this operation on was less than $100,000 -- and the damage to the Indian economy may already be $20 billion.

Arr, Matey!

Not too terribly far away, from an American point of view, Somali "pirates" have been very active, hijacking the Saudi-owned VLCC Sirius Star, a Ukranian vessel carrying Russian T-72 tanks and other weapons, a Yemeni steel carrier, and others.

Somalia has lacked a functioning central government since the early 1990s, and hasn't had a remotely democratic government since 1969. It's not much of a stretch to say it's never had a truly western-type democratic government. Regionalism and tribalism have led to breakaways (Somaliland), military rule, civil wars, and more or constant unrest.

One way to regard the Somali pirates is as disaffected and disadvantaged fishermen who can no longer operate in the current environment. With the officially recognized "government" of Somalia in control of less than half the country, the rule of law has disintegrated on a national level and local law is a mix of tribal law, Sharia, and old English common law left over from British Somaliland. Another way is to consider them regional terrorists or criminals. Which they are changes the long-term solution to the problem, but not the short-term one.

Regardless of their origins, Somali pirates (and their counterparts off Nigeria) are tightening the screws on the worldwide movement of goods, raising the risk of shipping and the price of goods, including oil. If they acquire the technology to threaten undersea cables, they could have the capability to dramatically disrupt electronic communication as well.

With American military forces stretched beyond their limits in Iraq and Afghanistan, the US doesn't have the muscle to maintain open sea lanes in the Gulf of Aden and off the Horn of Africa anymore. Many countries have been "free-riding" on the US Navy's ability to suppress piracy since WWII and especially once the US because the world's only hyperpower. As the limits to American power projection become clear, those nations are going to have to start stepping up with naval forces, on-vessel weapons and military personnel (or contractors like Blackwater), and money, which in the current economic environment may be the hardest to come by.

(Chart: Dow Jones Industrial Average, Yahoo Finance)

Melty, Melty Cheese

Anyone who doesn't know about the global financial meltdown of 2008 hasn't been paying attention. As of today, the Dow is down about 33% for the year, but ten days ago the Dow was down more than 43% for the year. From 2007.10.12 to 2008.11.20, the Dow dropped 46% from its high. At 8829, the Dow is now about where it was in March 1998.

Gold has dropped 20% from its historic high of about $1000, and at 813, it's close to the previous peak of January 1980. Many other commodities have dropped to 1/2 or 1/3 of their peak values over the last year, including Aluminum, Appalachian Coal, Cobalt, Copper, Lead, Nickel, Palladium, Platinum, Ruthenium, Silver, Steel, Tin, Uranium, and Zinc. At least some of those commodities have returned to their "normal" values of 5-10 years ago.

While a barrel of oil has dropped to about 1/3 of its peak price (currently $53 compared with a July peak of $147), it is still 2 1/2 times the historic average price of just over $20/bbl.

US electrical power use is dropping.

Dick Kelly, chief executive of Xcel Energy Inc., Minneapolis, says his company, which has utilities in Colorado and Minnesota, saw home-energy use drop 3% in the period from August through September, "the first time in 40 years I've seen a decline in sales" to homes. He doesn't think foreclosures are responsible for the trend.

China's growth rate is slowing. Fast.

Why then is China slowing so sharply? Simple, real estate investment has hit a wall. After growing at 20% y/y for a long time, real estate investment stalled – with a y/y growth rate of around 0% (Figure 5). That means that China is in turn producing more steel and cement than it needs, and producers of steel and cement are cutting back. That in turns hurts iron ore exporters…

This though is very much a result of China’s own policy choices. Rather than allowing the real exchange rate to appreciate back when China was truly booming (05-late 07/ early 08), China’s policy makers opted to rely on administrative curbs on credit growth. That left China more exposed to global slump in demand – as it kept exports up by limiting real appreciation even as it credit curbs limited the amount of froth in the real estate market back when China was booming and real interest rates were negative. China invested a lot in real estate, but it is no Dubai. But China’s policy makers still look to have slammed the brakes on a bit too hard. Rather than slowing gradually, real estate investment fell off a cliff.
...
While real exports contributed positive to GDP growth in 2008, they won’t contribute in 09. The World Bank forecasts that for the first time in a long time, 2009 real import growth will exceed real export growth. In 2005, real exports grew about 10% faster than real imports (23.6% v 13.4%). Many economists remain – for reasons that to be honest elude me – reluctant to draw the obvious connection: the most likely explanation for China’s strong real export growth is the large depreciation the RMB in 2003 and 2004. That combined with administrative controls – which limited lending, investment and ultimately imports – to create China’s large current account surplus. Real export growth exceeded real import growth by 5 percentage points in 2006 and 2007 – and by 4 percentage points in 2008.

The positive contribution of net exports to GDP is forecast to end in 2009: real import growth will exceed real export growth by 3 percentage points.

Oh, and the US has been in a recession for just about a year now. U-6 (an alternative measure of unemployment maintained by the BLS since 1994 or so) has hit a seasonally adjusted 11.8%, the highest ever recorded. We've lost about 1.2 million jobs this year, an especially stunning figure when you remember that we need 1.8 million new jobs a year to keep up with population growth. So we're down 3 million employed people in 2008.

In an effort to stop the meltdown, the US government has already committed at least a trillion dollars to the financial sector, and central banks the world over are scrambling to avoid a disaster.

Peak Experience

The good news is that the average US price of a gallon of gas is down to $1.825 as of 2008.12.01, a 56% drop from the record high $4.114 set on 2008.07.17. Even better news is that global petroleum demand is down:

Worldwide demand will decline by 20,000 barrels per day (bpd) in both 2008 and 2009 to 86.03 and 86.01 million bpd respectively, according to a Reuters poll of 11 analysts, banks and industry groups.

The slight fall is a large shift from a Reuters poll of experts in August, which forecast demand would increase by nearly 1 million bpd next year. Demand has not declined since the early 1980s, following the 1979 oil crisis and a severe recession in the United States.

"Global GDP growth is the main driver of oil demand, and with the economic slowdown we see global GDP rising by just 1.2 percent next year," Michael Lewis, head of commodities research at Deutsche Bank, said.

The bad news, of course, is why demand is down. US demand is expected to drop about 1 million bpd, or about 5% (other reports say 6.7%). That drop will be accompanied by a 1.4% drop in GDP in 2009. World GDP growth is expected to drop from 4% to 2.5% this year and under 2% next year.

Some might seem to be overreacting:

Make no bones about it, every past civilisation has decayed into the dry leaves of history - why should this one be different?

All those past efforts outgrew their carrying capacity, be it the Mayans with corn, the Sumerians with irrigation, or the colonist economies with dwindling extractables.

Anthropologist Jared Diamond catalogues them in his insightful book Collapse.

Those partial to more easily-digested literary offerings should try The Lorax, by Dr Seuss.

The message is identical: the collapse is usually a decline over decades or centuries, and that zero growth does not signal zero activity, just its peak.

Meaning we have to plan for a long, permanent recession.

Our society has been able to do so much more that previous ones, thanks only to the one-off use of fossil fuels.

The International Energy Agency has now signalled that we are past the peak of global oil supply, citing a cumulative depletion rate of 6.8% per annum.

7% Depletion Annually!!!!!!!

Ouch. Especially when you consider that a 1% drop in supply of oil can cause as much as a 20% rise in price.

Where Do We Go From Here?

Forecasting is fraught with peril. So rather than promoting a future, let us talk about several futures.

1) Whoopsie!

It's possible that the central banks and government intervention to save the financial sector will fail. This is a dire scenario, because a free fall (or "hard landing") of the US dollar, the Japanese yen, and the euro could leave the world without a reliable reserve currency. While the Chinese yuan might seem like an option, a tightly controlled currency (one that does not float in value according to market forces) will be unacceptable to many.

Without a stable reserve currency, the current credit crisis is going to seem like a mild spring compared to the depths of winter. Global trade will slow dramatically. Investment may halt except for government programs. The Great Depression could be a fond memory. We could be mired in slow or negative growth for a generation.

On the other hand, even this dread scenario could be considerably shorter-lived than the Depression of the 30s. Modern Keynesians believe they have a better handle on the events of the 30s and that they understand the necessary monetary moves to avoid another Depression. If they're right, our present slowdown, even with a hard dollar landing, might be largely over in 18 - 36 months.

A likely ending of this unpleasant scenario includes the world ending up with a non-dollar reserve currency. Maybe the euro, maybe the yuan is allowed to float, maybe the Indian rupee, but most likely some combination of currencies replaces the dollar.

During the downturn, no matter how long or short, economic unrest and lack of opportunity will fuel bigotry, prejudice, and terrorism. The fragility of the economic system will make it an attractive target for non-state actors, and we can expect a significant upsurge in worldwide violence and terrorism.

2) Whew!

If the Keynesians get control quickly and prove that they know what they're doing, the Great Recession of 2008 could prove to be the catalyst for the Great Green Growth of 2010 on. Monetary stimulus packages will encourage research and infrastructure spending aimed directly at the middle class and climate change. New industries will spring up and the US auto industry (now owned by a mix of union and government money) will lead the development and production of lower-carbon transportation options. Energy efficiency and lower-carbon energy generation will be fast-growth industries, leading eventually to a "green bubble" and correction.

Widespread economic improvement (not limited to the global elites) will begin to lift the "bottom billion". Jeffrey Sachs will be confirmed US Secretary of Global Equity and by 2020 the 2.5 billion people living on $2 or less a day will be living on $5 or less a day. The resulting prosperity will start a sharp decline in birth rates. Economically driven violence will decline.

Using a law-enforcement paradigm for anti-terrorism will not be entirely successful, but a combination of successful intelligence gathering and the rising economic fortunes of the global underclass will reduce worldwide terror and violence.

3) Whatever...

a) Peak Oil remains a concern. Even as the global downturn reduces demand for almost all non-food commodities, it also prevents private investment in commodity production/extraction. We will stumble along at 85-95 billion bbl for a while and between 2020 and 2030 we'll begin to see a serious decline in petroleum availability. The resulting spikes in price will revive energy investment. Who wins the race (declining petroleum supplies or alternative energy sources) is up for grabs (and government backing).

b) Global Terrorism and Violence are driven by economic factors as well as political ones. As the global economy declines and we reduce the carrying capacity of the environment, violent responses are the only options left for some. As globalism brings competing values into insular communities, clashes are almost inevitable. Fear of cultural annhilation drives the political use of violence. Getting off this treadmill requires re-visioning globalism and global aid. Large portions of the developing world are running out of easy (cheap or free) fuel sources. Aiding the bottom billion requires local knowledge, not just global money. Jeffrey Sachs has laid out a plan (pre-meltdown) which could reduce global poverty by spending roughly the US defense budget annually. We ought to be listening. The ultimate fix for global terrorism isn't military or even law-enforcement, it's economic and cultural.

c) From a bipolar superpower world we've gone to a unipolar hyperpower, and now that hyperpower has shown feet, knees, and even thighs of clay. The BRIC (Brazil, Russia, India, China) nations have the potential to re-alter the nature of world power politics. China and India are modernizing at a fearful rate, but neither is going to become a carbon copy of the US or Europe. China's interesting mix of totalitarian politics and unbridled economic capitalism has expressed itself in 8-10% growth but is now slipping. How they respond and what their political system looks like in a decade will tell us much about the world in 2100. India and Pakistan are looking at each other over Kashmir and considering what it would take to use nuclear weapons. Mumbai provides an excuse for the Indians to berate Pakistan. The Afghani conflict spills into Pakistan, provding conflict between Pakistan and the US (technically NATO, but....). A major regional conflict, possible with nukes, can't be ruled out, and would shape future politics in ways that we can't yet guess. We might go all "one world" or we might go all "every nuke for itself". Convincing Pakistan to rein in the ISI in a very public way would help a lot, but it's going to take more than that to decide about Kashmir in a way that leaves everyone involved willing to try for peace.

China's economic imperialism, especially in Africa, suggests that resource conflict over declining commodities, is inevitable. Proxy conflict over resources isn't impossible, and may even be likely. Keeping the conflict economic may slow recovery, but it will make for a more peaceful world so long as the conflict remains between more developed nations and doesn't spill over to the bottom billion. We could see a return to the proxy wars of the 70s and 80s in sub Saharan Africa but between the Chinese and everyone else instead of Soviet/US conflict.


What Condition Our Condition Is In


(Video: "Gutterballs" from the Coen Brothers' 1998 The Big Lebowski, starring Jeff Bridges, Julianne Moore, and John Goodman)

Well, I'm sorry to say it isn't exactly rosy. But it's not all black. Downturns provide the opportunity to change course, like layoffs can promote entrepreneurship. We still have choices that can improve our situation, although the combination of delay on climate change and the acceleration of the process leaves us with little time to react on that front.

If we want to prosper, investment on infrastructure is the key in the US. The trillion-plus we've spent on Iraq isn't doing nearly the economic good that it would do if invested in the US. The trillion-plus we're spending on the financial sector isn't doing nearly the good that it would do if invested in actual building and repair in the US. Sooner or later the small government people have to be thrown under the bus so the adults can get back to fixing the problem. If the US pulls out of free fall, other nations have both a safe haven reserve currency and a consumer of last resort (hopefully not quite as enthusiastic a consumer as the last few years). Recovery will exacerbate our Peak Oil problem, but some of that investment should be going to lower-carbon transportation, power, and agriculture.

We Are All In This Together....

There's more...

Thursday, June 19, 2008

"Drill Here. Drill Now. Pay Less." More Conservative Bullshit.



Newt Gingrich, primary beneficiary of the 1994 "Contract with on America", has started a "Drill Here. Drill Now. Pay Less." ad campaign in conjunction with last year's book, A Contract with the Earth. In classic Newtian fashion, DHDNPL breaks down into a small set of bullet points:


  • We have problems:
    • Dictators controlling US energy supplies
    • Billions of US dollars going overseas
    • Airline industry in trouble
    • Trucking industry in trouble
    • Food prices up
  • This is "a politician's energy crisis":
    • Liberal politicians deny us:
      • nuclear power
      • clean coal
      • shale oil
      • offshore drilling
    • We need to get the price of gasoline down in the short term
    • We need to increase alternative sources of fuel in the long term:
      • Hydrogen
      • Nuclear Power
      • Solar Energy
      • Wind Power

Let's look at them one by one and then overall, shall we?

We Have Problems
Absolutely, we do. No one paying $4 or more for a gallon of gas can deny that. And every one of Newt's bullet points is at least arguably true, even if his explanations for them are sometimes not so.

The US imported between 12.75 and 14 million barrels per day (Mbpd) during the month of May 2008 against a monthly average usage during Q1 2008 of between 19.75 and 20.8 Mbpd. That translates to importing about 2/3 of our petrochemical usage at a daily cost of $1.7 billion (assume 13.33 Mbpd @ $130) or about $630 trillion annually.

The Top Ten countries of origin for US petrochemical imports are (in kbpd, March 2008): Canada (2542), Saudi Arabia (1542), Mexico (1358), Nigeria (1174), Venezuela (1033), Iraq (772), Algeria (441), Russia (402), Angola (388), Virgin Islands (290). I think it's reasonable to consider that Canada, Mexico, Venezuela, and the Virgin Islands (about 5.2 Mpbd between them) are not ruled by dictators (although reasonable people can disagree) vs. 4.7 Mbpd that are. That still leaves 2.8 to 4 Mpbd unaccounted for, and countries like Libya and Azerbaijan on that list are certainly dictatorships, but I just can't put the Bahamas, Belgium, France, and Germany on that list.

Not All Problems are Energy Related
The Airline industry is certainly in trouble. But that's nothing new. In the 30 years since US deregulation of the airline industry, losses top gains by $13 billion, largely caused by overcapacity and the resulting downward price pressure. Energy prices don't help, but the industry wasn't making money when oil was cheap, either.

The Trucking industry is also suffering, but for different reasons. The average long-haul truck gets about 6 mpg in the US (other sources say 4.5 to 7.5), whereas Canada averaged 7.15 mpg in 1999. I read an article (can't find a source) suggesting that 10 mpg was within reach. In 2003, it was suggested that $1.40 diesel would drive truckers to improve their aerodynamics, tires, and transmissions. High speed raises fuel usage, and up to 50% of engine hours are spent idling. There are huge gains to be made by simple procedural efficiencies.

There is a lot of press about worldwide food prices. Some suggest that biofuels are causing the rise. But world coarse grain production peaked in 1996-1997 at 907 million tons and declined to 860 million tons in 2000-2001. Inconsistency in crop yields has reduced grain inventories worldwide. The cost of petrochemicals has unquestionably transferred some grain from food use to fuel use, but the essential problem of grain supply was with us before the current oil price rise. We have relied upon the "Green Revolution" to increase global food production and in doing so have outstripped our available carrying capacity.

Liberal Politicians Have Nothing to do With These Problems
In Newt's reality, we don't have infinite nuclear power, clean coal, oil shale derived petrochemicals, and energy independence because of offshore drilling because of "liberal politicians".

Aside from the fact that conservatives controlled the entire executive and legislative branches of government for several years there, Newt's blamefest for liberal boogiemen lacks foundation in other ways.

Both Congress and President George H. W. Bush have prevented offshore drilling: the 97th US Congress (House controlled by the Democratic Party 244 - 191, Senate by the Republican Party 53 - 46 - 1) banned offshore oil drilling in 1981; the first President Bush's executive order banned coastal oil exploration in 1990. It's hard to see how a split Congress and Bush 41 can be considered "liberal politicians".

Nuclear power has been stalled in the US since the Three Mile Island accident in 1979. No new plants have been built since 1973, although there are now multiple applications for nuclear plants before the NRC (pdf). Environmental concerns undoubtedly played a part in the unofficial moratorium, but low petroleum prices and an institutional switch to natural gas were almost certainly more important factors.

Clean coal has been a priority of the DoE during the present Bush administration. And isn't it funny how lack of action by energy companies becomes "liberal politicians locking us out of clean coal" while the Chinese work on it? Free marketeers like Newt always say that government incentives are distorting the market until they want incentives for their pet projects, and then the lack of those incentives is suddenly the fault of "liberal politicians". Clean coal is a wonderful idea if it can be done, but the fact that it's not happening is not about liberal politicians blocking it, it's about technical difficulty.

Oil shale? Like the Canadian tar sands, oil shale is tremendously dirty and difficult to extract economically. In Alberta, two-thirds of the extracted energy goes into the extraction process, along with huge volumes of water. It's not clear yet that the tar sands are energy positive and the ecological impact is enormous and obvious. Oil shale will be the same way in the US. We are not ready yet to safely and economically extract that energy, and we may never be ready. Liberal policies have nothing to do with it.

Gas Prices in the Short Term
The price of gas in the short term is driven by supply and demand, with additional complicating factors. Oil production* worldwide is about 86 Mbpd and closely matches demand. However, excess extraction capacity in the OPEC nations has dropped precipitously in the last few years. According to J. L. Williams at wtrg.com, OPEC spare capacity has dropped from 6 million bpd to under 2 million:

In mid 2002, there was over 6 million barrels per day of excess production capacity and by mid-2003 the excess was below 2 million. During much of 2004 and 2005 the spare capacity to produce oil was under a million barrels per day. A million barrels per day is not enough spare capacity to cover an interruption of supply from most OPEC producers.
In a world that consumes over 80 million barrels per day of petroleum products that added a significant risk premium to crude oil price and is largely responsible for prices in excess of $40-$50 per barrel

Without significant spare capacity, we lack extraction buffers against short-term supply interruptions like those happening in Nigeria or the 2006 pipeline shutdown in Alaska. Instead, we must rely upon post-extraction storage buffers like the US Strategic Petroleum Reserve.

*Oil "production" is more properly termed "extraction" because the process does not "produce" anything but merely "extracts" existing petrochemicals from one reservoir (presumably a natural one) into another (presumably an artificial one). I prefer the more correct term "extraction" not only because it properly explains the process, but because it reminds us that we are dealing with a fixed existing supply of material instead of the expandable output of a production line.

In the short term, supply and demand fundamentals explain a great deal about oil and gas prices. Concerns about future supply include militarism, nationalism, activism, accidents, weather, and resource nationalism. Some believe that these non-supply factors may account for $50/bbl of cost. Others believe that fundamentals adequately explain oil at $150 or even more. Others think we have plenty of oil and this is all some sort of speculator-driven conspiracy.



Alternatives in the Long Term

The best way to encourage alternative energy development is a combination of high energy prices and public policy. If public policy says that government will subsidize or prefer clean or renewable energy, then the market should respond relatively quickly. It is the very cheapness of petrochemicals (and the widespread externalization of pollution and other negatives) which has prevented the development of alternatives to this point. If we are in favor of non-petrochemical energy sources, we should be pleased about high petrochemical prices. I know it's hard, but that's why they call economics "the dismal science."



As for specific alternatives Newt likes, hydrogen isn't an energy source, it's just a storage medium. One of the major problems facing us is that petrochemicals are very energy dense. We can't build batteries that store energy nearly as well as gasoline does. Hydrogen (possibly in some kind of aerogel frame) is pretty promising in that regard.

Nuclear power has a definite place in our future, especially if pebble-bed reactors pan out. If so, we add 85 years of uranium (at current usage levels) to our energy supplies. Nuclear fission power is thus a bridging technology, which is exactly what we need while we finish developing long-term sustainable systems.



Solar, hydro, and wind power are true renewable technologies, and the high price of petrochemicals is encouraging development and deployment around the world. Subsidies would speed up deployment, but the market is taking care of that so long as the cost of oil remains high.



Typical Conservative Bullshit Posturing

"Drill Here. Drill Now. Pay Less." is a typical piece of bullshit Conservative posturing. Most of Newt's supporting points aren't, but that's not the worst of it. The solution won't solve any of the problems. Studies of ANWR show that drilling there will yield maybe $.01/gallon improvement in gas prices. In 2025. ANWR would deliver 875 Kbpd at peak and a total of about 10.4 billion barrels. Bush's plan for offshore drilling alleges 18 billion barrels, so we might suggest that the offshore flow would be double ANWR or about 1.7 Mbpd and so we might get another 3 - 5 cents off each gallon of gas.



In return for that 4 - 6 cents off a gallon of gas, this is what we get:

Oil spills. This is the 1979 Ixtoc I spill -- the largest accidental oil spill in history (only the deliberate release of oil during Gulf War 1 was larger) -- 140 million gallons spilled over at least six months. Despite Newt's lie that Hurricane Katrina couldn't knock out modern oil platforms, Katrina destroyed at least 46 platforms. And let me remind you that Exxon has still not paid their fine for the 1989 Exxon Valdez spill in Prince William Sound.



What DHDNPL will do is enrich American oil companies. As resource nationalism denies them access to major fields in Russia, Venezuela, and the Middle East, the non-national oil companies like ExxonMobil, RoyalDutchShell, and Chevron are trying to ensure their access to other sources. I'm sure that if politicians were to arrange for offshore drilling to be allowed in the US, they'd be richly rewarded.




Oh. I guess they already are.



Disclosure: I am passively invested in the extraction side of petrochemicals. I do not own stock in or have any active (decision-making) relationship with any company mentioned in the post.

[Updated 2008.06.19 0825 to remove reference to Argentina as a dictatorship. Guess I'm still living in the past :-)]
There's more...

Saturday, May 24, 2008

ANWR, Again

The government publishes yet another report on the effects of drilling for oil in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge:

Relative to the AEO2008 reference case, ANWR oil production is projected to have its largest oil price reduction impacts as follows: a reduction in low-sulfur, light (LSL) crude oil2 prices of $0.41 per barrel (2006 dollars) in 2026 in the low oil resource case, $0.75 per barrel in 2025 in the mean oil resource case, and $1.44 per barrel in 2027 in the high oil resource case. Assuming that world oil markets continue to work as they do today, the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) could neutralize any potential price impact of ANWR oil production by reducing its oil exports by an equal amount.
Again, we learn that ANWR will not save us at the gas pump.
There's more...