(Cartoon by Sean Delonas for New York Post, Wednesday, February 18, 2009)
Something's Happening Here...
It is, to deliberately use the phrase, as simple as black and white.
When you refer to African-Americans as simians, you are being racist. When you refer to European-Americans in the same way, it's not.
For at least a thousand years, people from Africa were denied inclusion in the human family by the cultural, religious, and political institutions of Europe. Insisting Africans were "not entirely human" but some kind of ape-being was not the cause of racism. Racism, like all other oppressions, begins with power imbalance based on perceived survival struggle which eventually becomes widespread enough to infect every system of the human cultures where it is found. At that point, justifications and rationalizations are created to "explain" the lie. The portrayal of black people as monkeys is an ancient attempt to excuse treating them like animals.
Follow the power. If a man is compared to a barnyard animal, it may be offensive but it doesn't threaten the power flow because there is no institutionalized lie which implies it might be true. If a woman is compared to a barnyard animal, it is an attack backed by possible denial of access to power. Which is why I don't use bitch, chick, sow, or cow as terms for women, any more than I would use buck, junglebunny, rat, or vermin to refer to various non-white groups. There is, in my opinion, no "reclaiming" of such terminology while the power structure remains intact, no "subverting" the fact that we are all raised to think of the lie -- and the hate behind it -- first when we hear it used.
The association is there, whether we admit it or not. Even the depiction of two white police officers shooting a chimp (although, in this case, the drawing looks more like a gorilla, which I believe is deliberate because gorillas are more intimidating) would have an underlay of recognizable racism, because a solid percentage of the American population will think "black" when they see that ape. It's an easy, cheap association.
But when the line "They'll have to find someone else to write the next stimulus bill" is the caption -- with the clear knowledge that our President wrote the current stimulus bill, and in fact a photograph of him doing so appears on the previous page of the same newspaper in which this so-called cartoon appeared -- then there is no arguing the intent of this drawing. The intent is to encourage feelings and thoughts of homicide against our President because he is an African-American daring to break free of his "animal" category, daring to assume economic leadership. Over white people.
I recommend reading BAGNewsNotes, who of course has their finger directly on the pulse. Also recommended is Jack and Jill Politics analysis in "The Connection Between Blacks As Apes And Police Brutality".
I also encourage us to think long-term about what this blatant display means. Pam Spaulding at Pam's House Blend does a consummate job of listing all the racism employed by Republicans and the Right during this last election cycle in her post The New York Post Makes Its Case For a Post-Racial America. It's true that this is business as usual for that crowd. But is also true that as the delusion of their supposed majority is revealed, and as they lose access to power, they will not go gentle in that good night. Their racism is, as Orcinus and Sara Robinson have repeatedly warned, becoming a daily danger, beyond even the threat of violence and death at the hands of cops that every person of color in this country knows on a gut level.
We cannot "nice" and hope this away. We cannot educate infected individuals and leave the system intact. This is not an issue of semantics or artistic freedom. This is a clarion clear call to war. We do not (and I hope will not) accept their terms of battle, but we must pay attention: When a major newspaper in our largest city prints a cartoon advocating the murder of "whoever wrote the stimulus bill", reducing him to an ape out of control, we are facing cultural revolution.
Something's happening here...
Thursday, February 19, 2009
Something's Happening Here...
Maggie Jochild 11:33 AM |
Labels: Bag News Notes, Jack and Jill Politics, Language, NY Post, Oppression Theory, Orcinus, Pam's House Blend, Racism, Racist dogwhistles
Monday, November 10, 2008
The New First Family at the Moment of Truth

Bagnews has a great thread up of this much talked about flickr view of election night with the family. I love these shots. I love what it says about them in absolutely natural and unassuming terms. I am so eager for 1/20 to be here. If I didn't have a great Christmas vacation planned I would be wishing to just lay down and sleep and wake up on 1/19...
Anyway, enjoy, and go over to the Bag thread and add your two cents (two yen-- two whatever ya got.) Also check out the full flickr set here.
Who's planning to be in DC in Jan.? I have heard talk of a Netroots party-- it would be great to see everyone there.
The Littlest Gator 3:20 PM |
Labels: Bag News Notes, Barack Obama, First Family, flickr, Inauguration
Saturday, September 20, 2008
Less Dorothy and More Like the Flying Monkeys
Our friend and fellow blogger, Michael Shaw over at Bagnews Notes has a great post up this week that I thought might be of interest to folks here since we have had a lot of in depth sometimes heated discussions about gender during this election season.
Bagnews is a blog about analyzing images in the corporate media.
The one in the last week that struck me was this;
Stephan Savoia/AP. Sept. 10, 2008. Fairfax, Va.
What do you think of this image? What do you think the AP is trying to say by running this one? Michael had some interesting comments,
The camera fascinates me. I wonder about the "demographics" of the audience members in this Fairfax, Virginia crowd and wonder how representative they are. (Class has definitely been on my mind as I've thought about this image, especially as the newswire has filled up lately with more pictures of enthusiastic women at Palin/McCain rallies. In that regard, what I find actually atypical about this image -- which should be good for an email, or two -- is how much younger and somehow "less-Republican" looking these women appear.) Of course, the shot is so sexually charged. And yet, I look at those shoes and I keep thinking: the Ruby Slippers. But then, I hate the analogy because I see Palin as more of a wannabe.I see less Ruby-Slippers/ Dorothy and more Flying Monkeys carrying away all the sensible sane governance of America and throwing it in a dungeon somewhere. (in Alaska perhaps?)
The choice of imagery shown with Palin stories also reminds me that a lot of the narrative about gender and the direction that the narrative has taken has been trumped up and manipulated by the media.
One story from early on in the Gov. of Alaska saga really struck me. When people were questioning her decision to run as VP when Palin has a pregnant teen and a new baby with downs syndrome; the media screeched that no one would ask these questions of a man.
That is utter bullshit.
As you know I was a big Howard Dean supporter in 03-04. Well early on, Howard's son was in a drinking and theft situation, and the media and GOP right wing blog types were yelling from the rooftops about how if he could not manage his family and help keep his kids out of trouble why in the world was he thinking of running for president?
Now that is not to say that sexism has not been a huge issue in politics. But I do remind myself, and am reminded by stories that run the picture above, that much of the narrative is manipulated by corporate media to sell advertising and get viewers eyes on their message. It would take a ton, not grains of salt to have a proper filter to view this stuff. There's more...
The Littlest Gator 6:39 PM |
Labels: 2008 election, Bag News Notes, Gender, Howard Dean, Sarah Palin, Sexism
Wednesday, August 6, 2008
Obamaphobia: Breaking the Frame

One of the highlights of NN for me was the panel on Framing with two of my heroes. Jeffrey Feldman was the moderator and our own "Gilly" winner, Michael Shaw was one of the presenters. He did an amazing section on visual framing going on in the MSM. If you know Bagnewsnotes, you know all about his work.
He and his son have just done an amazing job getting his presentation into slide-video form and getting it up on the web. Fascinating stuff. Take a look and listen.
I tried to embed it here, but the format is too large. So you have to go look over on the bag!
The Littlest Gator 5:41 AM |
Labels: Bag News Notes, Barack Obama, Election 2008, framing, Michael Shaw, Ombamaphobia, Photo analysis, The Frame Shop
Sunday, May 25, 2008
MIB: Obama to Bush/McCain, "I make this sh*t look good."

Some of you know that a few of us here at the GNB have been fans of BagNewsNotes for quite a while. If you haven't been over there, give it a tour. Basically, Michael is all about analysing the photos and visual images we are presented with in news and politics. The discussion over there is great and helps really break down and analyse the messages being played out underneath the spin, hype, and hyperbole.
This shot, from the NY Times really wow-ed me. The bagnewsnotes title was, "The First Post-American President?" and this and some other recent campaign trail photos of all three candidates have been the basis for some great discussion and information.
I really like this photo of Barack, he seems comfortable in his skin, cool and competent. This picture says to me, confidence but not arrogance. And yes, I know I am biased. But like I said, Bagnews does interesting shots and discussion of all the candidates and news, something for everyone.
h/t to Michael and Donna
(image: Doug Mills/The New York Times. May 22, 2008. Bozeman, Montana. via nytimes.com)
The Littlest Gator 12:03 AM |
Labels: Bag News Notes, Barack Obama, Election 2008, Photo analysis


