Open Thread/Live Blogging.
Looking forward to your comments below.
Both of them sitting at a table. And here we go...
McCain: Let's buy the home loan mortgages.
Obama: Worst financial crisis since great depression.
1. Focus on jobs.
2. Help families right away with middle class tax cut.
3. Fix energy policy. Fix health. Fix education.
McCain: Obama met plumber in Ohio named Joe. Sen. Obama's tax plan would raise taxes on your small business, raise taxes on Joe the Plumber.
Obama: He's been watching taxes of Sen. McCain. Sen. McCain's centerpiece is to give tax breaks to the wealthiest corporations in America. My plan gives a tax break to 95% of Americans. If you make less than $200,000 a year, your taxes will not go up one cent.
McCain: How Sen. Obama ended his converation with Joe the Plumber was, "We need to spread the wealth around." That's class warfare. Why would we want to increase anyone's taxes right now?
(Ed note: McCain is attacking STRONGLY. Doing very well. Obama needs to hit back hard.)
Obama: I have been a strong proponent of pay-as-you-go. If we invest now in health care that will make a difference in Medicare and Medicaid. If we invest now in energy we will be able to save money in the long run sent overseas.
McCain: First, I would have an across the board spending cut, and then I would get out a scalpel. I know how to save billions of dollars in defense spending. I believe in nuclear power.
Obama: An across the board spending freeze is a hatchet. Sen. McCain talks a lot about earmarks. They account for one-half of one percent. They're not going to solve the problem. Finally, let's talk about history. When President Bush came into office we had a surplus. Now we have a 10 TRILLION dollar deficit. Sen. McCain voted for President Bush's budget four out of five times.
McCain: Of course I can balance the budget in four years. If Sen. Obama wants to run against President Bush, he should have run four years ago.
Obama: You've stood clear of the Bush administration on torture and I admire that. However on
McCain: I've strongly disagreed with the Bush administration including the economy and the Iraq war.
Moderator: Will you say the tough things your campaigns have been saying, right here, right now, to each other?
McCain: If we had done the Townhall meetings then the entire tone of this campaign would have been different. I haven't lied in any of these ads. We are running a truthful campaign.
Obama: There's nothing wrong with a tough campaign. 100% of your ads are attack ads. But I think people are a lot less interested in our hurt feelings and in the issues.
McCain: I still don't hear a reputation of Congressman Lewis.
Obama: John, what's missing...
Ed note.... I'm having too much fun with this debate.... I'm just enjoying watching this. Going to stop trying to get every single word. It's just too damn good watching the future President of the United States be, well, Presidential. So I'll get some, most of it. Part of it. Probably. *smiles*
McCain simply looked like a CRANKY OLD MAN, whining and complaining about how the world isn't treating him fairly. Obama kept -- gently, carefully, as if McCain is an ill patient who is disturbed -- coming back to how important it is to take care of people, to treat everyone with respect, to shift the culture of politics.
****
Interesting. In the first part of the debate, McCain was on the attack. After the Ayers portion, when Obama so carefully handled McCain, and the moderator gave Obama as much time as he needed to deal with McCain's attacks, now McCain just sits there as Obama deals. Instead of what was going on at the start -- a slashing, full out back and forth, we're back to a more or less respectful question and answer. With McCain being slow on his answers.
Obama is clearly winning.
Roe v. Wade... Supreme Court conversation
Here's the difference between the two candidates.
Obama gives thoughtful, careful, nuanced, answers. McCain instead of dealing with the issue, goes for Obama's knees. He tries to slander, tear down, rip apart, destroy.
In short, McCain is lying. He KNOWS what Obama did, what happened. That is not sufficient. Instead, McCain attacks with clear lies.
Education is the final question.
Final Statements:
McCain: Difficult times and challenges. Need new direction. Can't be satisfied with the last eight years. I have a record of reform. I have been a careful steward of your tax dollars. All the promises I and Sen. Obama made to you tonight, will be based on if you can trust us. I've spent my entire life in the service of this country. There's been a long line of McCain's in the service of this country. I hope you'll give me the honor of serving you. Thank you.
Obama: This is the worst economic crisis since the great depression. That's why the worst risk we could take would be to take the same policies and same politics we've had for the last eight years and expect them to do anything else. I promise you if you give me the extrodinary honor of serving you, I'll (video/audio breakup...)
SUMMARY
OBAMA WINS.
Being Presidential: Obama
Character: Obama (by a lot)
Taking care of people: Obama (by a lot)
Trust: Obama
Knowing what he was doing: Obama (by a lot)
Defending against Attacks without hitting an old man needlessly: Obama
Being on the Attack: McCain
Lying: McCain (negative points)
Cranky Old Man: McCain (negative points)
Having to keep attacking and lying even though it's obvious he's lying:
McCain (forfit ALL points; lose the election)
Bottom line: Obama Wins
McCain came out swinging but lost when Obama treated him like the crazy old coot he is.
It's over.
I won't have the Snap Polls till tomorrow as my tonight is full.
My prediction: Obama wins with 370 electoral votes, maybe 400.
That's it for our debates.
LIVE from the GNB News Desk for 2008 Presidential Debate #3, this is Jesse Wendel. Remember...
YARD SIGNS DON'T VOTE. Go call someone.
Goodnight.
Wednesday, October 15, 2008
Presidental Debate #3: Open Thread/Live Blogging
Jesse Wendel 6:02 PM |
Labels: Barack Obama, Campaign 08, John McCain, Presidental Debates
Tuesday, October 7, 2008
Presidental Debate #2: Open Thread/Live Blogging
Open Thread/Live Blogging.
Looking forward to your comments below.
The Townhall format is claimed to be Sen. McCain's best. We will see.
Obama: The AIG executives who just went out and spent a bunch of money on a resort should have to give the money back to the treasury, and be fired. This is all McCain's people.
McCain: We need to have home mortgages bought back by the treasury.
McCain: The financial crisis is because of Fanny and Freddy. For two years some of us have been trying to stop this. Sen. Obama and his cronies have been taking campaign contribution for keeping this system in place.
Obama: The root cause of all of this is deregulation. Sen. McCain has been bragging about being a deregulator. The regulation bill is something that Sen. McCain jumped on a year after the bill had been in process a year after it was introduced. But you're not interested in politicians pointing fingers. You're interested in how this impacts you. What is needed now is regulation that makes sense. We need 21st century financial systems instead of the current 20th century markets. We need to work to bring
McCain: This economy may go up or down. It depends on what we do. The key will depend on if we stabilize the financial markets.
Question: How can we trust either of you with our money?
Obama: I understand both your cynicism and your skepticism. It's important to remember some history here. We had a surpless when George Bush came to office. Now we have a $10 billion dollar deficit, and Sen. McCain voted for 4 out of 5 of those.
We need to vote for healthcare, education, and other key policies. I intend to cut more than I'm spending. Key is priorities that are working for you.
McCain: I can see what you feel cynicism and mistrust. The system is broken. I have worked in a bipartisan way with Sen. Leiberman. Sen. Obama has never taken on the leaders of his own party.
Brokaw: What are your priorities?
McCain: We can do all three at once. We are not going to be able to pay for the people retiring in the future at the same level as the people currently retiring. (Ed note: MCCAIN IS SAYING, HE IS GOING TO CUT SOCIAL SECURITY BENEFITS.)
Obama: Our goal should be in ten years time we are free of our dependence on foreign oil. That would be priority number 1. Healthcare is number 2, because it makes our businesses more competitive. Number 3 is education. Because it makes our children more competitive in a global economy.
Ed note: This is happening against this background economically today:
YahooQuestion: What kind of sacrifice are you going to call the America people to?
Bank of America skidded 26.2 percent to $23.77 the day after it said it would cut its dividend and raise $10 billion to help staunch rising loan losses.
"The market can't seem to find a footing, no matter what the government or the Fed tells them. We're in uncharted territory and we don't know how that is going to end," said Linda Duessel, market strategist at Federated Investors in Pittsburgh.
"We've all been shellshocked by the momentum on the downside in this market, and now people are talking about a long and deep recession -- just a month ago, many thought a recession could be averted."
The Dow Jones industrial average fell 508.39 points, or 5.11 percent, to 9,447.11. The blue-chip Dow has lost more than 1,400 points over the past five sessions, or nearly 13 percent of its value, according to Reuters data.
The Standard & Poor's 500 Index dropped 60.66 points, or 5.74 percent, to 996.23 -- the first time the benchmark index has closed below the 1,000 level in more than five years. The drop was the S&P 500's biggest five-day percentage decline since the 1987 crash.
The Nasdaq Composite Index slid 108.08 points, or 5.80 percent, to 1,754.88.
McCain: People need to understand we can't do everything. We need to set priorities.
Obama: After 9/11 the entire country was ready to sacrifice. President Bush made some good choices, but also, he asked people to shop. I think that was a missed opportunity. People want to be called to service. This is why I'm proposing to double the Peace Corp for our young people. This is why... (gives several examples) ... where all of us are going to contribute, all of us are going to make sacrifices. Although I disagree with Sen. McCain about an across the board freeze. I think that hurts everyone. I think we need a scalpel.
McCain: Nailing jello to the wall. Last President to raise taxes during tough economic times was Herbert Hoover and he practice protectionism which I'm sure we'll get to. Sen. Obama's plan will raise taxes on over half a million small businesses. Let me be clear, I am not in favor of tax cuts for the wealthy. I am in favor of tax cuts for the middle class. Let's not raise anybody's taxes.
McCain: What's the best way to handle green issues? Nuclear power. I was on Navy ships. We can reprocess the fuel. Other countries do this. It creates jobs. We're the best innovators in the world.
Obama: This is one of the biggest challenges of our times. Not just a challenge but an opportunity. Can be an engine that drives us into the future like computers did. This will require a sustained effort from the next President. We have 3% of the world's oil reserves and we use 25% of the world's oil. This means we can not simply drill our way out of the crisis. We can then export this to companies like China which need energy.
Obama: Healthcare through your employeer. The rest are are covered through a plan which is the same is as good as the one the Sen. and I have. Sen. McCain's plan would be a tax credit, and result for the first time ever, in health care being taxed.
McCain: Deregulation. States.
Obama: I think Health Care should be a right. In a country as wealthy as ours, everyone should have health care. No one in my plan has to change plans, or has to change doctors. If you have a small business, you get a 50% credit to help. Everyone has to insure children, because all children should be insured.
McCain: Before we leave that, can we hear the size of the fine?
Obama: We've spent $700 billion so far. We're spending $10 billion a MONTH. That money needs to come home.
Brokaw: What is the doctrine for intervening in horrible situations, which are not U.S. wars?
Obama: I believe we need to consider intervening when a genocide is occuring. We need to work in concert with our allies.
McCain: The United States is the greatest force for good in the history of the world. That requires a cool hand at the tiller. We need to temper our decision making, and I've been doing this all my life. I will put the lives of our brave young people before anything except national security, knowing that I may have to make these hard calls.
Question: Should the U.S. peruse Bin Ladin in Pakistan?
Obama: If Pakistan is unable or unwilling to hunt down Bin Ladin, then we should.
McCain: "Speak softly and carry a big stick." Obama keeps talking big. We need to keep getting allies, to get the support of the people. Not to threaten to attack the people.
Obama: Sen. McCain is the same guy who sang "Bomb Bomb Bomb Iran" and called for the invasion of Iran. This is not what I call speaking softly.
McCain: I hate to even get into this; I was joking with an old friend about the Iran thing. Sen. Obama and I have fundamental differences about this. I am unwilling to telegraph my plans. I know how to get Bin Ladin and I will.
McCain: We want to bring international pressures on Russia in the hopes it will modify their recent behavior. It will not restart the cold war.
Obama: In addition to financial assistance to the territories, we need to see around the corners. We need to anticipate what is going to happen before it happens. We need to be much more strategic. Energy is going to be key in dealing with Russia. If we can reduce the amount of oil we use, that reduces the amount of money they have to make mischief.
McCain: Of course we would defend Israel. The big issue is iran's committment to gaining nuclear weapons.
Obama: We can not allow Iran to gain a nuclear weapon. It would be a game changer. It is unacceptable. I will do everything that is required to change it. It is important however, that we do everything possible to work with other countries, to tighten sanctons on Iran, if we keep putting the squeeze on Iran, that helps. I do believe that we should have direct talks not just with our friends but with our enemies, so we can deliver a message that says
Question: What don't you know, and how do you learn it?
Obama: It's never the challenges that you expect. It's the ones you don't that end up consuming most of your time. I wouldn't be standing here if it wasn't for that this country gave me the opportunity. The question in this election is, are we going to pass on that American Dream to the next generation, or see it vanish, as we've seen it go away over the last eight years. We need FUNDAMENTAL CHANGE in this election. That's what is at stake, but we need the nerve and courage to make the jump.
McCain: What I don't know is what is going to happen both at home and abroad. What I don't know is what the unexpected will be. I grew up in a family where my father was gone most of the time doing our countries business. My mother raised us. I know what it like to rely on your comrades. I'm asking the American people to give me that chance.
Brokaw: Next debate, October 15.
SUMMARY
OBAMA WINS.
Being Presidential: Obama
Being on the Attack: McCain
Character: Tie
Lying: Tie
Trust: Obama
Smart ass/arrogance: None --> Obama
Knowing what he was doing: Obama
National Security: McCain, by a nose. (And I hate to say it.)
Bottom line: Obama Wins
Overall, McCain did a LOT better than Debate #1. The Townhall format is by far his best format.
Problem is, it isn't enough to stop the bleeding.
McCain hit hard on national security. In the world of undecideds, I'm guessing on tonight only, McCain went up slightly over Obama slightly. But Obama clearly won the debate, probably 2:1.
Okay... MSNBC has the first set of dial groups coming in. They are precisely what I predicted. 60/40 for Obama overall, and 2:1 in independents. Neither independents or dems like it when McCain goes negative. Also not even Republicans in the dial group think the McCain's mortgage plan is worth anything; they want a full economic plan.
We will see how the snap polls are when they come in.
The other two big issues for me are, Obama said health care is a right, McCain said it is a responsibility. And McCain said he wants to alter social security.
This was not a game changer. Obama is ahead. He is going to stay ahead. Obama will win, I predict, by at least 100 electoral votes, and probably at 400 EV.
It's been FUN. Thanks for being here. Coming up as soon as we have it, SNAP POLLS.
LIVE, this is the GNB News Desk, covering the 2008 Presidential Debate #2. I'm Jesse Wendel. Goodnight. There's more...
Jesse Wendel 6:05 PM |
Labels: Barack Obama, Campaign 08, John McCain, Presidental Debates
Friday, September 26, 2008
Presidential Debate #1: Open Thread/Live Blogging
Open Thread/Live Blogging.
Looking forward to your comments below.
So far, Obama has missed a number of chances to hit back hard. And McCain keeps lying.
6:26 pm:
McCain is lying about tax breaks. He's simply lying.
Obama says, "That's simply not true", and hits back with "Your plan would give the oil companies $4 Billion dollars." McCain looks like an OLD man, totally at a loss for words.
Obama needs to just say, YOU ARE LYING. Is it possible for you reply without lying?
6:38:
Obama: You voted with the President 95% of the time. How can you say now you're against the budget when you were for it?
McCain: I'm well known as the Maverick of the Senate. I was against the Budget, against the war, against everything, and I'm glad I have a Maverick with me as a partner.
OH MY FUCKING GOD. And the moderator just moved on to the next question. Oh.My.God.
6:45:
Obama is on the attack, big time.
McCain: Senator Obama doesn't understand the difference between a strategy and a tactic. Then tells a story about soldiers reenlisting. Then LIES about Obama on cutting funds for troops. Again.
Obama cuts him short. Says that simply isn't so. Said also, I DO understand difference. Here is difference. Furthermore, here is how we should do this. And this is the result.
McCain is winning on raw emotion. He is reaching his base.
Obama is on the defense. He keeps having to say, "that's not true, that's not true." That is DEFENSE.
Obama needs to rock McCain back on his heels. Obama needs to CLOBBER McCain.
McCain is lying all over, but they are simple lies, lies which will work with McCain's base, and with simple undecideds who don't pay attention. People vote on emotion and character and trust. Onama is defending and McCain's simple lies may work for this debate if Obama doesn't get off his ass and KICK MCCAIN IN THE FUCKING BALLS. In a post-partisan way.
7:00
McCain keeps telling stories. It's all about stories for McCain.
Obama is clearly fed up with McCain.
Problem is, being fed up comes across. The undecideds are not going to like this.
McCain is also coming across as, um, bluffing. He's obviously not as smart as Obama. He is obviously a D- student against a Harvard A+ Honors graduate.
Oh fuck. Obama just made a fucking PUN. Dumb, dumb, dumbshit.
STOP BEING THE SMARTEST KID IN THE CLASS. Now he's playing back and forth doing careful pronunciation between Iraq, Iran, and centrifuges. Jesus.
Well, we're going to see who wins the debate.
The SMART KID WHO IS CLEARLY RIGHT AND EVERYONE KNOWS IT, or the DUMB LYING ONE WITH LOTS OF EMOTION.
It is going to come down to how bad everyone thinks this shit is. If people think this shit is TRULY bad, Obama wins. If people think it isn't that bad, they'll give it to the old white guy. Anything before giving it to the ni***r arrogant smart ass who knows everything. You only vote for him if EVERYTHING is fucked. Truly everything.
So the outcome of this debate (the polls three days from now) will tell us how people view how bad things are. 'Cause Obama sure as hell has failed to take this to McCain. He is STILL coming across as the smart kid, and McCain is still the dumb guy who lies and tells stories that don't really have any point.
7:15
Obama: A resurgent Russia is a threat. You can not be a 21st Century Superpower and act like a 20th Century Dictator.
Nearby countries should be free to join NATO and we should have a action plan to bring them in.
We need to work with Russia, not based on staring into his eyes and seeing his soul, not to go back to the Cold War, but to head off nuclear proliferation.
McCain: I look at Putin and I see only three letters: K and G and B. It's all about oil.
Obama: It isn't just about oil. It's about solar and other alternate fuels.
McCain: It's about drilling. Drill offshore. And nukes. That is what will make the difference. Obama is totally against nukes.
Obama: No, actually, what I said was, you have to store the fuel safely. Once again you are misrepresenting me.
McCain: adfadfadfgadjglaj (Talks over Obama. Again.)
7:26
PBS: How much safer are we now than after 9/11?
McCain: Much safer than the day after.
Obama: Need to focus on harbors. Nuclear proliferation. Gives credit to McCain for his work on torture (Ed note: Idiot... You don't give points to your opponent during your close.) And (missed this one. Sorry.)
Final Statements
McCain: Obama doesn't get it. Withdrawing from Iraq, date certain means everything would be lost if we do what Obama says.
Obama: Over the last eight years, the administration and Sen McCain have been solely focused on Iraq, while Bin Laden is active and not captured. While China is loaning us Billions of dollars and they are active everywhere. We are missing what they are doing, not to mention our economy is being destroyed while our military and veterans affairs are ruined because of the destruction of the economy due to this war and lack of a broad strategic vision. That is what I'm looking to restore.
McCain: We've seen this stubbornness before in this administration. We need more flexibility in a President of the United States. The veterans know me and love me, and I love them. I'll take care of them.
Ed note: WHAT! McCain just compared Obama's plan for withdrawing from Iraq, more accurately, McCain's LIES about Obama's plan for withdrawing from Iraq, with Bush's staying in Iraq: "We've seen this stubbornness before in this administration." Holy SHIT. McCain simply can NOT STOP LYING.
Obama: In the 60s my father who came from Kenya, wrote letter after letter to come to college, because the notion was no other country in the world was you could make it if you tried. Part of how we're going to make America safe is, we're going to invest in issues like education, issues that make ordinary Americans safe.
Jim: October 2, Vice Presidential Debate
SUMMARY
OBAMA WINS.
Being Presidential: Obama
Toughness: McCain
Character: Obama
Lying: McCain --> Obama wins big-time!
Trust: Obama (See Lying) --> McCain loses big-time!
Smart ass/arrogance: Obama --> McCain wins
Story telling instead of knowing what he's doing: McCain --> Obama wins
Bottom line: Obama Wins
Because when the shit hits the fan, you don't turn to the D- student with good stories and a golf game. You turn to the smart person who knows what the hell they're doing, a well-designed plan, and enormous patience. In moments of crisis, you don't want a hot-head running the show; you want someone fully trustworthy.
McCain did well on toughness but really what he had was stories. McCain obviously failed at having the facts. So he lied. Over and over again.
Obama did great on facts, but not so great on emotion. Obama failed to kick McCain's ass or put him on serious defense. So Obama ended up on defense to McCain's emotion with "So that's just not true" and "Well that's just not true" followed by explaining to McMain what the facts in question actually were. And how much they cost!!
McCain kept speaking over Obama. We could say Obama let him, or McCain didn't give Obama a chance to speak. I think both are valid. The old guy may simply not have heard Obama, Obama may have simply been being polite or not wanted to be rude to his elder, or on the flip side, McCain may have been aggressive, and Obama may have been unwilling to contest the floor. Regardless, McCain comes out the looser I think, over the long-haul. He looks distracted and unaware. The framing/direction by the PBS camera team didn't help him, as he was cross-framed, looking in the wrong direction. Plus McCain himself was always hunched over, refusing to ever look Obama in the eye.
McCain looks petulant, old, and angry.
Obama looked Presidental. He demonstrated patience. He showed control, control of the facts.
Jesse Wendel 6:17 PM |
Labels: Barack Obama, Campaign 08, John McCain, Presidental Debates


