Showing posts with label POW. Show all posts
Showing posts with label POW. Show all posts

Thursday, September 18, 2008

What Bothers Me the Most

Graphic by The Dark Wraith

About John McCain's Story of His Capitivity


Finally hit me. I was reading a well written (as always) and brutally reasoned (as usual) essay by the Wraith using as his foundation an article written by McCain's cousin, in the St. Petersburg Times.

Like me, the the cousin and the Wraith were set to wondering:

What happened to John McCain?

All have their own theories. Instead, I was focused into something I've been trying to organize in my head and write for a while.

McCain's tale of being a POW is pervasive and a centerpiece to his self-proclaimed qualifications for the job of President. His behavior while a POW, under extreme and brutal circumstances is a story of endurance, stubborn resistence, patriotism, and just about every exemplary behavior in the range of human conduct.

That's that part that was bugging me though. It's too consistently good.

Three tours of Vietnam, and most of those tours spent in areas of pretty hot action. (LRRP's, Search and Rescue, Aerial bombardment spotting, and some pure ass sanctioned murders with a long rifle) One thing I've come to understand is that when the circumstances for me were extreme, my behaviors and conduct were also in the extremes.

Consistency was not something I saw much. A perfect example is the battle at Dong Ap Bai right at the beginning of Tet. I received the Silver Star for something I did there. Please though, do not judge my conduct, or my behavior, or my worth as a human being, or even my competence as a soldier, citizen or warrior by that decoration. The actions surrounding that award took about 15 minutes out of a three day fight. Yes, the events pretty much happened the way they were reported. I did run out and expose myself to some pretty heavy fire and bring a wounded officer to a place of shelter, I did, while still under fire, do my level best to treat his wounds. I did have to stop twice while rendering aid to devote my full attention to the fight that didn't call time out for me to do any of this. Oh, yeah, the officer in question was a good guy. He was also the son of a Marine Brigadier General. We had gone through BUDS together and we were a bit more than close. He was also a lousy but habitual poker player and I always liked that in an officer. There were acts of heroism and gallantry going on all over the place that day. Mine was noticed because of who else was involved. It really is that simple. If the guy I helped hadn't been who he was, I probably would have been another nameless grunt in another nameless action out in the boonies. Over the full course of that fight my conduct ranged to encompass just about every exteme of human behavior, from base to sublime, from noble to shameful. Fifteen or so minutes was singled out and after that it was the approved and accepted norm.

Oh, yeah, I was also pretty high on pot and dexamils the whole time.

To hear John McCain talk about his conduct as a POW you get this stable and consistent narrative of nobility that rings very false with me. When pressed he will admit to one time when he broke and delivered the signed confession that his captors were demanding. I'm not ever going to hold that against him. McCain, while a captive, possessed eyewitness knowledge to the Gulf of Tonkin incident, which had he divulged would have been very damaging to American interests and the negotiations that eventually ended the war. He never gave up anything important, but then, that wasn't what his torturers wanted. They wanted their bullshit confession, and a badly beaten, terribly degraded and humiliated John McCain co-operated with them because he had been tortured to the absolute limits of his endurance.

If John McCain had told his story to sound something like "I was young, cocky and arrogant, (which are not unusual qualities in Naval Aviators or Admiral's kids) and I did the very best I could. I often failed in living up to my own standards and insignia, but, I did my level best every single day." That's something I would buy willingly. To suggest that his behavior under those unimaginably extreme circumstances was anything approaching consistent beggars my imagination.

I wasn't even able to predict my own behavior accurately from moment to moment. In combat, each moment is a discrete little universe, apart from all the other little moments. I had times of gallantry, but also of terror. Times of courage and times of fearful despair. Like I said before, there was a little of everything in that mix.

A few hours after the actions which were cited to give me my medal I was in a muddy trench berm trying to dig myself a little further down with my bare hands to get another fraction of an inch safer from the goddamned mortars and rockets that were flying in. Great. Big. Fucking. Hero. Right? I saw guys who had been incarnations of Hector, Achilles, and Ajax break up and down over silly shit like news from home. I saw guys that fell apart, and pulled themselves back together again. Just like I did over and over.

It might be that McCain's construction of memory around his captivity is cruicial to his psychological survival. It might be that remembering only the times when he was doing shit right is the only way he's able to get through the days.

If his experience is anything like mine, there are probably some things he remembers vividly that if you asked the folks to his right or his left were not perceived in the same way by other folks that were right there with him.

I will, with confidence, call Bullshit on the consistency. John McCain is all too human. Like the rest of us. I will forgive him his lapses and failures in that situation if he promises to forgive mine.

Thing is I don't want my President to be somebody who has, at the very core of their consciousness, a vested interest in keeping a fiction alive. We've had enough of that kind of crap over the last seven years.
There's more...

Thursday, September 11, 2008

Obama Or Else

Obama Or Else postcard by Liza Cowan (Obama Or Else postcard by Liza Cowan)

Obama Or Else

They say in Spider Solitaire, theoretically every hand is winnable. I never have the patience to try thinking through each move or using "undo" to make a crappy layout winnable. In fact, if on the first layout I don't have several moves to expose hole cards, I'll usually re-deal. But that's just a game. It's not deciding who will become the most powerful leader in the world.

I got a direct challenge from a precious friend yesterday, Liza Cowan, who was a leader before I was out of junior high, whose blazed trail literally saved my life. She's an artist, not a politician, but she said "We have to win this election. There's nothing more important right now." She's 59 and has two children about to enter adolescence (her second go-round at parenting). They've both girls, so she's not looking at them being drafted if McCain wins, but she's sharp enough to not see that as a consolation because she lived through the Vietnam era draft, which scarred us all in different ways. She's made the decision to do at least one thing every day, one concrete action, to make sure Obama wins this election. She asked me to do the same.

So here we go. My goal is to come up with a simple act you can do every day that, directly or indirectly, helps us put a sane, accountable human being in the White House and/or restore basic human rights to the daily life of America. I'll aim for an action besides donating money, because (a) giving money is something we already know how to do and (b) if you're like me, you don't have money to give. Although as Liza says, lots of people can afford ten bucks.

There's two main reasons to engage in direct action like this. One is that this groundswell is what this election is all about -- it's how we've gotten this far. The Republican strategy is to feed their extremist minority with a VP choice whose extremism they're keeping under wraps and pass it off as populism, i.e., "She's a hockey mom". They pacify their corporate overlords by NEVER passing legislation which benefits the average working person, and they dupe the rest of the country into voting for them by any lie available. They lie, they lie, they lie. But we are ravenous for the truth out here, and direct action will bring you into contact with the truth. You'll feel better afterward.

The second reason is that we are afraid and feeling some degree of despair about how things are going. It's bad out here, and looks to be getting worse. We've gotten out of the habit, in too many ways, of learning how to deal with these feelings. We take drugs, we watch TV, we complain on a blog, we sit at home and snark at our family. We think it may be too late. We want reassurance that we have not made a disastrous series of mistakes which have dumped shit in our own backyards, destroyed our economy, made us a joke in the rest of the world, and divided our landscape into enemy camps. We want Hope. And Change.

But the reality of hope and change, we're starting to realize, involves work and mess. Some people don't know how to step past the despair to do the actual work, and for those folks, McCain is offering Change Lite. He's offering absolution -- or, for those of you without a Christian background, atonement/redemption without fasting or self-examination. Except, of course, the bill will come due the day after he's elected, with interest and penalty charges.

The only way through despair is through it. Don't make any major decisions while you're at your worst; accept any offer of help; and move your body/mind according to the best thinking you had before you got desperate until you feel a little better. Keep going ("Proceed as the way opens"), and eventually you'll arrive at Change. The key is to move. Taking action is a direct contradiction to despair. Don't spend a lot of time processing it in advance, just act and process later if necessary.

Today's suggestion comes from Democracy For America. They've put together a 30 second video they're thinking about running on TV, which consists of excerpts of an interview with Phillip Butler. As their explanation states, "Dr. Phillip Butler is a veteran and a former prisoner of war at the “Hanoi Hilton” with Sen. McCain. He knows the real McCain. Now he has shot a 30 second ad with our friends at Brave New Films to make sure Americans hear the truth."

We've already run the extended interview from which this ad was taken here at Group News Blog in the post by The Littlest Gator Being a POW Is Not A Resume Builder.

Click on this link for Democracy for America, watch the video if you have not already, and tell them yes if you'd like to see wider exposure. Of course the point of this, from their vantage, is to add names to their database and hit you up for money. But they're a good place to donate if you agree with their strategy, and you don't have to give money to add your voice to this movement. I'm not affiliated with them in any way, by the way -- this is just about the video. Here's a transcript of the DFA ad:

Screenshot of Phillip Butler, Commander U.S. Navy (Ret.), POW Hanoi 1965-1973. (All items in quotes below are spoken by Dr. Butler.)

"Hell, I'm 70 years old and I've lived through being a prisoner of war, I'm going to tell it like it is.

A fellow POW on John McCain: Reckless. Erratic. Unfit to lead.

"The prisoner of war experience is not a good prerequisite for a President of the United States. He was well-known as a very volatile guy, and he would blow up and go off like a Roman candle.

"John McCain is not somebody I would like to see with his finger near the red button."


The YouTube URL for this longer interview is here. You could send this to everybody in your e-mail box (especially all those friends and relatives who are not solidly Democratic) with the Democracy for America link to contradict the fairly wacky notion that being a prisoner who was tortured over 30 years ago makes someone a good President, especially since John McCain has refused to outlaw torture by our own government. (Can somebody please check the box "Fails to learn from own experience"?)

And, lagniappe for today: The postcard graphic at the head of this post was designed and printed by Liza Cowan. She's already given away or mailed out a thousand of them, and she's extending an offer to the readers of Group News Blog: Send her a self-addressed stamped envelope with postage of 59 cents on it, and she'll mail you ten of these postcards for your own use. The addy is Pine Street Art Works, 404 Pine Street, Burlington, VT 05401. Or, if you or your organization wants more, e-mail her at Liza(at)pinestreetartworks(dot)com. If you use this graphic elsewhere, please be sure to give her copyright credit and link to her blog.

I welcome comments about what you've done today, or recently, to get our Democrat in the White House or more progressives in government. Feel free to share suggestions. Just, please, don't blog whore (i.e., use this as an opportunity to promote an individual's blog instead of that belonging to an organization or a particular cause) and don't engage in hate speech. If Obama is not your first choice, that's fine, find another action which DOES promote your vision of progressive government and tell us about that.

There's more...

Tuesday, September 2, 2008

Being a POW Is Not a Resume Builder

Great video from a fellow Vientnam POW and Vet. I know many of us have already seen this, but it is still worth posting and sharing widely. Especially in reaction to his "Palin-poll-bump."


We don't want to make John's war experience political, but he does so I think it is fair to hear from people that offer an alternate view.
There's more...

Friday, August 29, 2008

Noun, Verb, POW

Image by Darkblack (Extra thanks to Darkblack for this inspiring image.)

Noun, Verb, POW

I have a friend named Jamila who years ago handed me a phrase to live by. Before I go on, let me affirm yes, Jamila is an Arabic name: She was raised white Catholic in Iowa but she has converted to Sufi and it has made her extremely happy. If you can't get past that, you're not the intended reader of this article.

So, what Jamila said was: "Any difficulty I have with your difficulty is still MY difficulty."

It's the ultimate statement of personal responsibility. It means it's my work, my life lesson, my nudge from g*d, however you want to phrase it, when I encounter emotional resistance to your obvious emotional resistance.

This does not mean you can reduce institutional and systemic forms of oppression to "emotional resistance" on the part of those employing it. You have to trace the source of power, and if it comes from societal, cultural, and governmental institutions, you are NOT reduced to seeking therapy for how oppression has fucked you up (although it doesn't hurt to get it), you have a right to demand CHANGE.

But in a great many of our personal interactions and reactions, "privilege" is not what's going down. What's going down is that someone we're listening to is showing damage, and how we interpret and respond to that is OUR responsibility, not something they "make" us feel or do.

Any difficulty you have with my difficulty is still YOUR difficulty.

There's been an obvious wish, if not displayed tendency, on the part of Democrats to play the age card with John McCain, i.e., "He's too old to be President." I won't go there, mostly because it's just wrong -- it's ageist. Competence is not measured by years, and the Constitutional measure for the office of the President is 35 years. I have known plenty of 25-year-olds who are far less sharp and able to track than John McCain.

Instead, I think we should be up front about the issue of competence itself, and how we define it. In this I would include mental stability. I think it's clear, at this point, that George W. Bush was (and remains) mentally unfit for the responsibility of leadership. He's immature, he's vindictive, he's incurious, he's immature (did I say that already?), and he lacks personal insight to such an extent that he's volatile. He is clearly damaged.

I personally believe that this damage was visible before he was elected and that, perversely, it's why a lot of people voted for him, especially white men. I think his damage is what "someone I'd like to have a beer with" is code for: He's just like me, and why can't I be good enough to run for President? If you're sick of being a failure, of being told by your boss and wife and family and even some of your friends that you're not handling what is expected of you, if you're called privileged but you feel like every other group gets special consideration and hell your parents raised you to be absolutely no more than what you've accomplished, then that anger will latch onto another wretch as a role model.

This is partly the result of hurling "privilege" accusations at folks instead of labeling systems of oppression, targets and non-targets for oppression: Personalizing the oppressor simply has not worked. Nobody "feels" like the "oppressor"; no kid is specifically raised to be the overlord, the bad guy, the eater of all extra (even when they are.) Every human being is targeted in at least one way for subhuman treatment, and every human being is trained in the ways of treating another group of humans with subhuman disrespect. This has to be sorted out on a one-on-one basis while still identifying the major flows of power -- race, gender, class, age, religion, geography, physical ability.

Because we were in the midst of the Right's framing of seeking personal insight as "feminine" behavior (pussy, faggy, liberal, hippie, atheist), we as a nation chose in 2000 to adopt a vigorously "masculine" approach: Just make a decision, dammit, someone else will clean up any mess. Look firm and strong-jawed, that's all that counts. Now we're in the position of housewives everywhere, looking at the living room where an eight-year Superbowl party of immature teenaged old boys have never once been told No. In some parts of the room, we'll have to rip down to bare studs and rebuild.

If you can face this job without utter despair, congratulations: You've acquired the human conditioning which is, in our Right-skewed culture, labeled "female" but which is in reality (and in other cultures) known as adult.

But, as any experienced housewife can also tell you, we have to learn our lessons from this indulgence. And one lesson we need to pick up, as a nation, is the ability to judge and value competence. We have to assess mental competence and signs of damage.

I'll be brave here: John McCain is showing obvious signs of damage. What is the main clue? He'll tell you right away. He was a POW.

Now, not all POW's remain damaged from their experience. Some PTSD survivors are able to completely eradicate any negative vestige of their experience from their behavior. (I speak from personal knowledge here.) Many others, perhaps most, can clean up enough so that the deep scars manifest only occasionally, with particular and rare triggers. You have to get past feeling shit on for having been traumatized in the first place, accept the work of recovery and pursue it resolutely until your life is your own again. Sucks, but that's the drill.

At age 13, in 1968, I became an anti-war pacifist. My parents were both at that time Republicans who voted for Nixon, so you can guess how well this went over. I never missed a chance to vocalize my beliefs, and consequently my adolescence was a sore trial for us all. I made straight A's, didn't use drugs, played sports and won state-wide academic contests, so my parents didn't feel like they could ground me for my political beliefs, although I'm sure they talked it over. I wore on my mother enough that by 1972, she didn't vote for Nixon a second time. (Hee hee hee.)

It therefore confused them, and some of my friends, when in 1972 I purchased a POW bracelet at the State Fair in Dallas and swore I would not take it off until that man was either freed or his remains identified. I saw no contradiction in my belief system: Being anti-war meant defending the rights of those caught up in the war machine against torture and imprisonment.

That year, my senior year, I was captain of my local basketball team, a starting forward. The second game of the season, during warm-up one of the referees went to my coach and told him league rules stipulated no jewelry could be worn during a game, and that included my silver POW bracelet. As we filed into the locker room for our final lecture, Coach told me the news: The bracelet had to come off for the game.

I explained to him what the bracelet symbolized and that I could not possibly justify removing it for a basketball game. He was, in addition to coaching and teaching (badly) algebra, the local Baptist deacon, and I'm certain both he and the ref had a snicker together about the thrill of forcing that symbol of hippiedom from my body. He was adamant. My choice was to either take off the bracelet or sit out that and every other game for the season. He shouted at me a minute, then stormed out of the room.

My teammates were devastated. They didn't all agree with me, but they knew I would not budge. One of them, a former best friend who had been born again and renounced me two years earlier in an unacknowledged lesbian panic, actually sat on the end of the bench and prayed to herself. It was her who came up with a solution: She retrieved the thick white tape we used to wrap sprained joints and wrapped it around my wrist, over the bracelet, until all traces of its outline were concealed. I went out with the rest of the team to start the game. Coach of course knew what was going on, but somebody told him whose idea it was -- the good Baptist girl -- and he let it slide. I went through the season with a wrapped wrist. And no, we didn't win that game or most of the others. I was a crappy player on a crappy team. This is not a Rudy story.

I was watching TV in 1973 when my POW walked off a plane onto U.S. soil again. Sobbing, I pulled the bracelet from my arm and traced the engraved name one last time: Lt. Commander John S. McCain.

When the vote came up before the U.S. Senate to redefine torture and reiterate our stand against it as a nation, I wrote John McCain personally, telling him the story I shared above and asking him, not as a constituent of his nor even a party member but as an American who loves her country -- beseeching him to stick to his principles and lead the way against torture. He never responded, even with a form letter, and we all know how he voted. I wasn't personally offended, but I did understand what it meant: He's not recovered in any meaningful way from his experience 30 years ago.

If you look at his personal history, he's shown no concrete evidence of recovery in other areas. He's betrayed personal loyalties, he's pursued wealth the easy way, he has serious anger control issues, he leaves hard work to others, and he cannot maintain his own proclaimed principles. These are not "senior moments", this is a classic PTSD profile. When he answers basic questions by first referencing his having been a POW, he's telling us that this is the defining moment of his personality, the box he's never managed to escape, what comes up inside him at every turn, out of his control.

I have compassion for him. I wish he belonged to a culture that believed in seeking thorough help and putting the experience behind him. But my compassion doesn't alter my rational opinion that he's not competent to assume leadership, especially not military leadership. It's an opinion I get to make as a voter, not based on the lies of oppression or bigotry, and I'm taking the opportunity to state it here because I suspect there are others who want the relief of hearing it. The damage you receive along the way (and kids, my childhood would curl your toes) is damage, not character, and it is important you do whatever you can to clean it up before you ask others to accommodate it. We do have a right to ask our sisters and brothers to accommodate our scars. I personally choose to live in forgiveness. But forgiveness does not mean handing a drunk the keys to my car.

No to McCain BECAUSE he approaches leadership from the mindset of a POW.

There's more...